Offices in Bridgeport · Decatur · Rhome · Class 3+ impact-rated shingles on every roof Call (817) 733-9228
Snow Roofing & Exteriors logo

Free Roof Replacement Estimate

📞 Call (817) 733-9228
Blog

Pine-Crest Stone-Coated Steel Shake vs. Real Cedar Shake in Colleyville: Fire, Hail, Weight, Decking and Upkeep

By Blake Snow, owner ·

Two panels: a crew installing natural cedar shakes, and a close-up of stone-coated roof panels
Illustration

Colleyville still has plenty of homes that wear a cedar shake roof, and plenty more where the owners love that look but are tired of what cedar asks for. One option I get asked about is stone-coated steel shake, and in particular Westlake Royal’s Unified Steel Pine-Crest Shake.

I’m Blake Snow. I’ve been roofing for 30 years, and we install cedar, synthetic shake and stone-coated steel across Colleyville, Southlake and Keller. Here’s an honest side-by-side using the manufacturer’s documents, the code evaluation report and the cedar industry’s own bureau.

Pine-Crest vs. cedar at a glance

Unified Steel Pine-Crest ShakeNatural cedar shake
MaterialGalvalume (AZ50 aluminum-zinc) coated steel, 0.017” coated thickness, stone granules in acrylic with a clear acrylic glazeSplit or sawn western red cedar
FireClass A in a listed assembly (Sol-R-Skin BLUE or GAF VersaShield underlayment)Untreated has no fire-retardant treatment; Certi-Guard treated comes in Class B or C, and Class B with a special assembly makes Class A
HailClass 4 and FM Very Severe Hail (on min. 15/32” plywood)Bureau says cedar is highly impact-resistant; test results are manufacturer-specific
Weight1.5 lb per sq. ft. (about 150 lb per 100 sq. ft.)Varies by species, grade, thickness and moisture
Minimum slope3:12 (below that it’s decorative and must go over a code-compliant roof covering)Per code and the bureau’s application rules
Installed exposure14-1/2” x 50” panelsPer shake length and grade
WarrantyTransferable 50-year limited (Westlake Royal)Bureau-administered manufacturer’s lifetime limited warranty on Certi-label products installed by a member contractor/installer
UpkeepMinimal, per Westlake RoyalTreat for fire or moss/mildew (not both in one treatment), replace split shakes, keep it clean and drying
Average lifeNot stated beyond the warrantyAbout 30 to 40 years, per the bureau

Sources: Westlake Royal’s Pine-Crest Shake page, QAI code evaluation report CERus-1008 (published July 2022, expires July 2028) and the Cedar Shake & Shingle Bureau FAQ.

Where real cedar still wins

I’ll say it plainly: nothing looks exactly like real cedar, especially up close and as it silvers. The Cedar Shake & Shingle Bureau also points out that premium-grade shakes, with grain running straight down the shake, curl less, and that treated “Certi-Last” products tend to last longer than untreated. If your heart is set on wood and your HOA wants it, we’ll build a cedar roof the right way, on a deck and underlayment plan that lets it dry.

The trade-off is upkeep. The bureau says you can treat cedar for fire retardancy or for moss and mildew, but not both in one treatment, and it doesn’t endorse topical fire-retardant sprays. In our heat and storms, plan on ongoing inspections and shake replacement.

Where Pine-Crest wins

  • Fire, on paper. Pine-Crest reaches Class A in the listed assembly. For cedar to get there, you need Class B treated shakes plus a special assembly.
  • Hail rating. Westlake Royal lists Class 4 and FM Very Severe Hail. The QAI report ties those ratings to a minimum 15/32” plywood deck.
  • Weight. At 1.5 psf, it’s a light roof. We still check the framing and deck on every tear-off.
  • Upkeep. No staining, no fire retreatment, no moss treatment.
  • Warranty. A transferable 50-year limited warranty from Westlake Royal.

The decking question on a cedar tear-off

Older cedar roofs often sit on spaced boards so the wood can breathe. That matters when you switch:

  • The QAI report allows batten installs over spaced structural sheathing that meets code, with minimum 2x2 wood battens.
  • But the report’s Class 4 / Very Severe Hail assembly lists a minimum 15/32” plywood deck.
  • Direct-to-deck installs go on solid sheathing too.

If the hail rating matters to you or your insurer, plan on solid plywood. We put it on the quote as its own line so you can see it.

Colors and matching

Westlake Royal’s Unified Steel bulletin lists Pine-Crest in Barclay, Charcoal, Gold River, Harborwood, Ironwood, Stirling Gray and Timberwood. Pick from real samples in daylight. Westlake Royal itself says online colors may vary from actual tile.

If you already have an older Gerard stone-coated roof, Westlake Royal’s bulletin lists Pine-Crest as the replacement for some discontinued Gerard and Metro shakes, but flags them as dissimilar in size or color, so they won’t match an existing roof. See our Gerard and Unified Steel repair-matching guide first.

Colleyville permits and HOAs

Colleyville requires a permit on every re-roof, and contractors have to be registered with the city. We handle the permit. If you’re in an HOA, we’ll put the Pine-Crest product sheet, color sample and fire and hail ratings in your submittal.

Other ways to get the shake look

After hail on either roof

Hail damage on cedar and stone-coated steel can be hard to read from the ground. Get a free inspection with drone and thermal imaging and a digital photo report. You can look up past storms near you in NOAA’s Storm Events Database. Hail is an insurance claim, not a warranty claim. In Texas you generally have 1 year from the date of loss to file, but check your policy. The Texas Department of Insurance says insurers set their own impact-resistant roof credits, so ask your agent before you choose.

What goes on our shake roof quotes

  • Product and color (Pine-Crest, cedar grade and treatment, or composite)
  • Deck plan: solid plywood or battens over existing boards, and why
  • Underlayment, including the Class A layer where required
  • Flashing metal, ridge, rakes and ventilation
  • Permit and HOA submittal
  • Free digital photo report, and our workmanship warranty from 10 years up to lifetime, depending on the job

Talk to us about a shake roof in Colleyville

We install shake-look roofs in Colleyville, Southlake, Keller, Grapevine and Westlake. Westlake Royal Unified Steel roofs are installed to manufacturer specs by certified installers. We’re certified with GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, Atlas, Johns Manville, Carlisle, Tropical Roofing Products, Mule-Hide and Enviroshake, and many other roof manufacturers. We’re BBB A+ rated, with 5.0 stars on Google at all three offices: Bridgeport, Decatur and Rhome. Request a free inspection or call (817) 733-9228.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

What is Pine-Crest Shake?

Pine-Crest Shake is a stone-coated steel shake panel in Westlake Royal's Unified Steel line. Westlake Royal lists Class 4 hail impact resistance, FM Very Severe Hail, Class A fire, hurricane wind performance and a transferable 50-year limited warranty. The QAI code report lists a 14-1/2 x 50 inch installed exposure and a product weight of 1.5 pounds per square foot.

Is Pine-Crest Shake lighter than cedar?

Pine-Crest weighs about 1.5 pounds per square foot, roughly 150 pounds per 100 square feet of roof, per QAI report CERus-1008. Cedar weight varies with species, grade, thickness and moisture, so we weigh the actual comparison on your roof rather than quote a generic number.

Is a cedar shake roof fire rated?

Only if it is treated and installed in a rated assembly. The Cedar Shake & Shingle Bureau says pressure-impregnated fire-retardant (Certi-Guard) shakes come in Class B and Class C treatments, and Class B treated product used with a special assembly creates a Class A roof. Pine-Crest reaches Class A in a listed assembly that includes Sol-R-Skin BLUE or GAF VersaShield underlayment, per the QAI report.

Can Pine-Crest go over the spaced boards under my old cedar roof?

The QAI report allows batten installs over spaced structural sheathing boards that meet code, but its Class 4 and Very Severe Hail assembly lists a minimum 15/32-inch plywood deck. If you want the hail rating your insurer may ask about, plan on solid plywood. We price it as its own line item.

How long does a cedar shake roof last?

The Cedar Shake & Shingle Bureau puts the average life span at about 30 to 40 years and says it depends on grade, installation, climate, exposure and maintenance. Pine-Crest carries Westlake Royal's transferable 50-year limited warranty, which covers the product, not storm damage.

Does insurance cover hail damage on either roof?

Hail damage is an insurance claim, not a manufacturer warranty claim, for either roof. In Texas you generally have 1 year from the date of loss to file a claim, but check your policy. Ask your agent whether a Class 4 roof qualifies for a premium credit before you choose.

Get a free roof inspection

We get on the roof, photograph what we find, and tell you plainly whether you need a repair or a replacement.

Free Roof Replacement Estimate

📞 Call (817) 733-9228

Certified with GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, Atlas, Johns Manville, Carlisle, Tropical Roofing Products, Mule-Hide and Enviroshake

Atlas Roofing certified contractor
📞 (817) 733-9228