After a hailstorm in Keller, the question I hear right after “Is my roof damaged?” is “If insurance replaces it, what should I put back?” More and more homeowners want a Class 4 impact-resistant shingle, and the two names that come up most are CertainTeed Landmark ClimateFlex and GAF Timberline AS II.
I’m Blake Snow. I’ve been roofing for 30 years, and Snow Roofing & Exteriors is certified with both CertainTeed and GAF, so I don’t have a horse in this race. This post compares the two head to head using each manufacturer’s current data sheets and 2026 warranties, plus what Texas insurers typically ask for when you put a Class 4 roof on. If you’re deciding between two GAF shake-look Class 4 shingles instead, see my Grand Sequoia vs. Grand Sequoia AS post for Keller.
The short answer
- Both are UL 2218 Class 4 and both use rubberized (modified) asphalt to get there. Neither one is “hail-proof,” and neither manufacturer warranty covers hail.
- ClimateFlex comes in the classic Landmark look, and CertainTeed adds a strict install note: clean deck only (no roof-overs) for the Class 4 rating, with impact-resistant ridge caps strongly recommended.
- Timberline AS II comes in GAF’s Timberline look, and when installed with the required GAF accessories it’s eligible for GAF’s WindProven wind warranty with no maximum wind speed (15 years).
- For the claim and the discount, what matters most is paperwork: Class 4 wrapper photos, matching IR ridge caps, the invoice, the permit, and any insurer form such as TDI’s PC068.
Side by side: what each manufacturer publishes
| CertainTeed Landmark ClimateFlex | GAF Timberline AS II | |
|---|---|---|
| Impact rating | UL 2218 Class 4 (at time of manufacture) | Passes UL 2218 with Class 4 rating |
| How it gets there | Polymer modified asphalt (SBS modified, per CertainTeed’s applicator manual) | Proprietary SBS-modified asphalt |
| Size | 13¼” x 38¾” | 13¼” x 39⅜” |
| Exposure | 5⅝” | 5⅝” |
| Pieces per square | About 66 | 64 (3 bundles) |
| Weight per square | About 229 lb | Not listed on the spec sheet |
| Fire | UL 790 / ASTM E108 Class A | UL 790 Class A |
| Wind classification | ASTM D7158 Class H; ASTM D3161 Class F | ASTM D7158 Class H (excludes Seal-A-Ridge AS); ASTM D3161 Class F |
| Texas listing | “Meets TDI Windstorm Requirements” | “Texas Department of Insurance listed” |
| Matching IR ridge cap | Shadow Ridge ClimateFlex (strongly recommended) | Seal-A-Ridge AS |
| Class 4 install condition | Clean deck, no roof-overs | Install per GAF instructions |
| Algae warranty | 25 years with algae-resistant hip and ridge (10 without) | 25-year StainGuard Plus on packages with that logo |
| Colors | Regional; ask for full-size samples | Barkwood, Charcoal, Hickory, Pewter Gray, Shakewood, Slate, Weathered Wood |
Sources: CertainTeed’s Landmark ClimateFlex technical data sheet, applicator manual section, 2026 limited warranty and product page; GAF’s Timberline AS II spec sheet (01/2026).
The warranties, compared honestly
Manufacturing-defect coverage. Both are “lifetime” limited, transferable warranties, and both define lifetime around the original individual owner of a single-family home (with limits for other owners). CertainTeed adds 10 years of SureStart protection on ClimateFlex. GAF ties its strongest coverage to installing GAF Lifetime shingles with qualifying GAF accessories under its roofing system warranty.
Wind.
- CertainTeed: ClimateFlex is warranted to 110 mph, with an upgrade to 160 mph for the first 15 years when the shingles aren’t installed over an old roof and CertainTeed’s matching starter and hip and ridge products are used.
- GAF: the 15-year WindProven limited wind warranty has no maximum wind speed, but only for shingles with GAF’s LayerLock technology installed with GAF starter strips, roof deck protection, ridge caps, and leak barrier or attic ventilation.
Hail. This is the part most people get wrong. CertainTeed’s 2026 warranty lists “damage caused by lightning, hailstorm…” among its exclusions, and refers you to the data sheet for impact information. GAF says it “makes no express or implied warranty about the impact performance of these products against hail.” So with either brand, a Class 4 rating is about performance and insurance, not a hail warranty.
The install details that keep it Class 4
These are easy to skip on a rushed storm job, and they’re what an adjuster or underwriter may look at later.
- No roof-overs. CertainTeed says Landmark ClimateFlex must go over a clean deck to get the UL 2218 Class 4 rating. Its upgraded wind warranty also excludes roof-overs. We quote a full tear-off to the deck on Class 4 jobs, whichever brand.
- Impact-resistant ridge caps. CertainTeed strongly recommends Shadow Ridge ClimateFlex caps on all hips and ridges and warns that some insurance carriers may not treat the roof as UL 2218 Class 4 compliant without them. For GAF, the matching cap is Seal-A-Ridge AS.
- Class 4 wrappers. Insurers check labels. We photograph the bundle wrappers showing the Class 4 statement on delivery day, along with the ridge cap boxes.
- Nailing and accessories. Both makers publish nailing patterns and accessory requirements for their warranties. We follow the one for the brand you pick and list the accessories on the quote.
What insurers typically ask for
The Texas Department of Insurance explains it plainly on its impact-resistant roofing credits page:
- A Class 4 roof covering “would receive the highest premium credit.”
- The amount of any discount is set company by company.
- Each insurer decides which tests it accepts, how products must be labeled, and what paperwork the contractor and policyholder must send.
- TDI’s form PC068 (Impact-Resistant Roofing Installation Form) is filled out by the contractor after installation. TWIA requires it for its credit; other insurers may use it or their own form.
I can’t promise you a discount, and nobody else honestly can either. What I can do is hand you a complete file. On a Class 4 job, here is what we put together for you:
- Photos of the Class 4 wrappers and ridge cap boxes
- An invoice that names the exact shingle and ridge cap product lines
- The permit and final inspection record
- PC068 or your insurer’s own form, filled out on request
- Our free digital photo report of the finished roof (drone and thermal imaging included with every inspection)
Before you choose, call your agent and ask: What credit do you give for UL 2218 Class 4? Which form do you need? Do you treat SBS-modified shingles differently? Does my policy limit coverage for cosmetic hail damage?
If insurance is replacing your Keller roof
- Get it inspected and documented soon after the storm. In Texas you generally have 1 year from the date of loss to file a claim, but check your policy.
- Know what the policy pays for. If your current roof isn’t Class 4, ask your adjuster or agent how an upgrade is handled before you sign anything.
- Pick the product, then the color. Both lines come in colors that suit Keller’s brick and stone homes; ask to see full-size shingles on your house.
- HOA first, then permit. Many Keller neighborhoods review roof color. Texas Property Code § 202.011 limits how an association can block impact-resistant shingles that look like what’s allowed, but it can still review color. Some associations name products outright. Timarron, next door in Southlake, lists both “CertainTeed Landmark series … Hail Resistant” and “GAF Timberline Armorshield II series … Hail Resistant” on its Type I roofing list. Check your own documents.
- Permit. We confirm Keller’s current permit requirements and pull what’s required. My Grand Sequoia post covers Keller permit basics.
Look up past storms for Tarrant County in NOAA’s Storm Events Database, and see our recap of the August 26, 2026 hail in Keller, Haslet and Alliance.
Which one would I pick in Keller?
Honestly, either one is a good roof when it’s installed right, and I’d steer you by these questions rather than by brand:
- Do you like the Landmark look or the Timberline look better on your house? Look at full-size shingles against your brick or stone in daylight. That decides more jobs than any spec.
- Does your HOA name one line? Then that’s usually the easy answer.
- Is wind a big worry on your lot? If you’re on an open, exposed lot, GAF’s WindProven terms are worth comparing with CertainTeed’s 160 mph upgrade.
- Matching nearby roofs or additions? If part of the house or a detached building already has one brand, staying with it keeps colors close.
If you want to look past these two, see my posts comparing Owens Corning Duration FLEX vs. STORM and Atlas Pinnacle Impact vs. StormMaster Shake, our best Class 4 shingles for Texas guide, and our Class 4 roofing page for Keller.
What goes on our Class 4 quotes
- Brand and line (Landmark ClimateFlex or Timberline AS II), color, and a note to photograph Class 4 wrappers on delivery
- Full tear-off to the deck (no roof-overs), with a deck repair allowance
- Matching impact-resistant ridge caps (Shadow Ridge ClimateFlex or Seal-A-Ridge AS) and the manufacturer’s starter
- Underlayment, leak barrier, drip edge, flashing and ventilation, plus the accessories the chosen warranty requires
- Permit and inspections as Keller requires
- PC068 or your insurer’s form, and a free digital photo report
- Our workmanship warranty, from 10 years up to lifetime, depending on the job
Talk to us about a Class 4 roof in Keller
We replace roofs across Keller, Southlake, Colleyville, North Richland Hills, Roanoke and Fort Worth. We’re certified with GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, Atlas, Johns Manville, Carlisle, Tropical Roofing Products, Mule-Hide and Enviroshake, and many other roof manufacturers. We’re fully insured, BBB A+ rated, and have 5.0 stars on Google at all three offices: Bridgeport, Decatur and Rhome.
See our CertainTeed Landmark and GAF Timberline pages and our storm damage page, use the estimate form below, or call (817) 733-9228.
Sources
- CertainTeed: Landmark ClimateFlex product page
- CertainTeed: Landmark ClimateFlex technical data sheet (04/25)
- CertainTeed: Landmark Series applicator manual section
- CertainTeed: 2026 asphalt shingle limited warranty
- GAF: Timberline AS II spec sheet (RESGN467TAS-0126)
- GAF: Timberline AS II product page
- Texas Department of Insurance: Products qualifying for impact-resistant roofing credits
- Timarron Owners Association: Design Review Guidelines, April 2025
- NOAA NCEI Storm Events Database

