Offices in Bridgeport · Decatur · Rhome · Class 3+ impact-rated shingles on every roof Call (817) 733-9228
Snow Roofing & Exteriors logo

Free Roof Replacement Estimate

📞 Call (817) 733-9228
Blog

Slate Grade and Thickness in a Westlake Slate Roof Quote: What S1, 1/4" vs. 3/8" and "Sorted" Should Mean

By Blake Snow, owner ·

Close-up of a natural slate roof with a copper valley and slates of varying thickness stacked for sorting
Illustration

Two natural slate quotes for the same Westlake home can be tens of thousands of dollars apart, and both can say “natural slate.” The difference is usually hiding in three words most homeowners skip: grade, thickness and sorting.

I’m Blake Snow. I’ve been roofing for 30 years, and we install and repair natural slate across Westlake, Southlake and the Park Cities. Here’s how to read a slate quote so you know what you’re actually buying.

Grade: ASTM C406 S1, S2 and S3

ASTM C406 is the U.S. standard for roofing slate. It grades slate on three lab tests, and the grade predicts how long the stone holds up to weather:

ASTM C406 gradeMin. breaking load (C120)Max. absorption (C121)Max. depth of softening (C217)Expected service life
S1575 lb0.25%0.002 in.Over 75 years
S2575 lb0.36%0.008 in.40 to 75 years
S3575 lb0.45%0.014 in.20 to 40 years

Notice the breaking load is the same for all three. What separates them is how much water the stone absorbs and how much it softens in the acid test. Those are what make slate flake, delaminate and fail over decades.

What to ask for:

  • The grade in writing. “Premium slate” isn’t a grade. S1 is.
  • Test results for that quarry and color. Reputable quarries publish them. New England Slate, for example, lists breaking load, absorption and softening numbers for each of its colors.
  • No ribbon slate on the field. ASTM C406 excludes slate with soft carbonaceous “ribbons” because its service life is uncertain.

The Slate Roofing Contractors Association’s architectural standard calls for S1. On a Westlake estate roof, that’s what I recommend too.

Thickness: what “1/4 inch” really means

The National Slate Association says standard roofing slate today is nominal 1/4” or 1/4” to 3/8”, and that 3/16” is no longer commonly produced. “Nominal” matters: slate is split by eye, so a 1/4” order will include some pieces closer to 3/16” and some closer to 5/16”. The NSA says about plus or minus 1/16” is the tightest tolerance you can reasonably ask for.

Thickness drives weight, and weight drives framing:

Nominal thicknessApprox. weight per square (3” headlap)
3/16”675 to 700 lb
1/4”935 lb
1/4” to 3/8”1,170 lb
3/8”1,405 lb
1/2”1,870 lb

Figures from the National Slate Association and North Country Slate. For comparison, synthetic slate is a fraction of that (see our synthetic vs. natural slate post).

If your home never had slate, the framing has to be checked for that load before we quote it. We’ll tell you up front.

Graduated roofs and sorting

  • Uniform roof: one length, width and thickness. Clean and formal.
  • Graduated roof: longest, thickest slates at the eaves, getting shorter and thinner toward the ridge. The NSA notes eave slates can be 1” or more and 3/16” at the top. It’s the classic look on grand Tudor and Georgian homes, and it costs more in material and labor.
  • Sorting: even on a uniform roof, slates should be sorted by thickness before they go up, so the roof lies flat and looks even. If a quote doesn’t mention sorting, ask.

What else separates a 100-year slate roof

What goes on our natural slate quotes

  • Quarry, color, and ASTM C406 grade (we recommend S1) with test results
  • Nominal thickness and tolerance, and whether it’s uniform, intermingled or graduated
  • Size, exposure and headlap
  • Sorting by thickness before install
  • Nail type (copper or stainless), flashing metal and weight, underlayment
  • Free digital photo report, and our workmanship warranty from 10 years up to lifetime, depending on the job

Have an older slate roof? Read natural slate repair vs. replacement before anyone tells you to tear it off.

Talk to us about natural slate in Westlake

We install and repair natural slate in Westlake, Southlake, Trophy Club, Colleyville and Highland Park. We’re certified with GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, Atlas, Johns Manville, Carlisle, Tropical Roofing Products, Mule-Hide and Enviroshake, and many other roof manufacturers. We’re BBB A+ rated, with 5.0 stars on Google at all three offices: Bridgeport, Decatur and Rhome. Request a free inspection or call (817) 733-9228.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

What does S1 grade slate mean?

ASTM C406 classifies roofing slate as S1, S2 or S3 based on three lab tests: breaking load (ASTM C120), water absorption (C121) and depth of softening after acid exposure (C217). S1 has an expected service life of over 75 years, S2 40 to 75 years and S3 20 to 40 years.

What are the S1, S2 and S3 test limits?

All three require a minimum 575 lb breaking load. Maximum absorption is 0.25% for S1, 0.36% for S2 and 0.45% for S3. Maximum depth of softening is 0.002 inch for S1, 0.008 inch for S2 and 0.014 inch for S3.

How thick should roofing slate be?

The National Slate Association says standard roofing slate today is nominal 1/4 inch or 1/4 to 3/8 inch, and 3/16 inch is no longer commonly produced. Thicker slate is heavier, costs more to ship and install, and usually has more texture.

How much does a slate roof weigh?

The National Slate Association puts nominal 1/4 inch slate at about 935 lb per square (9.35 lb per sq ft) with a standard 3 inch headlap, and 1/2 inch slate at about 18.7 lb per sq ft. A home that never had slate needs its framing checked before slate goes on.

Is S2 slate bad?

Not bad, but shorter-lived on paper. For a Westlake estate roof that's supposed to outlast the mortgage by decades, I'd want S1 in writing. The Slate Roofing Contractors Association's architectural standard calls for S1.

Does insurance cover slate roof damage?

Storm damage like hail or wind-broken slates goes through your homeowners insurance. In Texas you generally have 1 year from the date of loss to file a claim, but check your policy.

Get a free roof inspection

We get on the roof, photograph what we find, and tell you plainly whether you need a repair or a replacement.

Free Roof Replacement Estimate

📞 Call (817) 733-9228

Certified with GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, Atlas, Johns Manville, Carlisle, Tropical Roofing Products, Mule-Hide and Enviroshake

Atlas Roofing certified contractor
📞 (817) 733-9228