Snow Roofing & Exteriors logo Call (817) 733-9228
Blog

Should I Replace Gutters When Replacing My Roof? A Flower Mound Roofer's Answer

By Blake Snow, owner ·

Dark shingle roof with matching dark gutters and a downspout along the eaves of a brick home with a garage
Shingle roof with dark gutters and a downspout at the eave

Should I replace gutters when replacing my roof? It’s one of the most common questions I get on Flower Mound estimates, and the honest answer is: not always. Sometimes your gutters are fine and just need to come down and go back up. Sometimes they’re the weak link, and putting a new roof above them is like buying new tires and keeping bald brakes.

I’m Blake Snow. I’ve been roofing for 30 years, I’m the third generation in a family business that goes back 75 years, and we replace roofs all over Flower Mound, Highland Village and Double Oak. We also install seamless gutters, soffit and fascia, paint and windows, so I don’t have a reason to push you one way or the other. Here’s how I decide.

The short answer

  • Keep them if they’re straight, tight to the fascia, sized right and not leaking. We take them down, roof, and rehang them.
  • Replace them if they sag, leak at the seams, are dented by hail, overflow in hard rain, or are a color that won’t work with the new roof.
  • Check the fascia first. If the wood behind the gutter is rotten, the gutters are coming down anyway.
  • The new roof is the cheapest time to do it, because the eave is already open and the crew is already there.

Why the roof and gutters meet at the same spot

At the bottom edge of your roof, three things overlap: the drip edge (the metal angle at the edge of the deck), the fascia (the board the gutter is fastened to) and the gutter itself. The drip edge is supposed to carry water off the shingles and drop it into the gutter. If the gutter hangs too low or sits in front of the drip edge, water runs behind it, down the fascia, and rots the wood.

The residential code requires drip edge at the eaves and rakes of asphalt shingle roofs, and drip edge is part of the trim on our shingle roofs. That’s the moment the gutter has to be lined up right. If the gutters are good, they go back on under the new drip edge. If they’re not, it makes no sense to hang worn-out gutters on a brand-new edge.

When to replace gutters with your new roof

1. They sag or pull away from the fascia

Sagging runs hold standing water after a rain. That usually means worn hangers, or hangers screwed into soft wood. Old spike-and-ferrule gutters loosen over time. New gutters should hang from hangers screwed into solid fascia.

2. The seams and corners leak

Look under the inside corners and end caps after a rain. A dark streak down the fascia or brick is a leak. Sectional gutters have a seam every few feet, and every seam is a future leak. Seamless gutters are formed in one piece for each run, so the only joints are at corners and ends.

3. Hail dented them

Gutters and downspouts are soft metal, and around Flower Mound they take a beating. NOAA’s Storm Events Database lists 4.25-inch hail about 1.3 miles from the center of Flower Mound on June 11, 2023, and 3.5-inch hail about 2 miles away on March 14, 2024. Dented gutters and downspouts help show hail size during an inspection and are usually part of the claim with the roof. If a storm hit your home, see our Flower Mound storm damage page. In Texas you generally have 1 year from the date of loss to file a claim; check your policy.

4. They overflow in a hard rain, even when clean

That’s a sizing problem, not a cleaning problem. Usually the downspouts are the bottleneck. This Old House rates a 2x3 downspout at about 600 square feet of roof at 1 inch of rain per hour and a 3x4 at about 1,200, and North Texas storms often rain harder than that. Adding a downspout near a valley, or going to 3x4 outlets, fixes a lot of overflow. On big homes, my post on oversized gutters and downspouts goes deeper.

5. The fascia behind them is rotten

This is the one that changes the plan. Once the gutter is off, you see the fascia for the first time in years. Soft or patched boards have to be replaced before anything gets rehung, because a hanger screwed into rotten wood won’t hold a gutter full of water. Since the gutter has to come off to fix the fascia anyway, rehanging an old gutter on new wood usually isn’t worth it.

6. You’re changing the roof color or material

A new charcoal roof with faded white gutters can look off. And if you’re switching to a metal roof in Flower Mound, metal sheds water faster than shingles, so I check each run’s size and the downspout count. We make seamless gutters in colors matched to your roof or trim.

When it’s fine to keep your gutters

If your gutters are straight, pitched toward the downspouts, tight to solid fascia, free of seam leaks and big enough for the roof above them, keep them. We take them down where needed, put the roof on, and rehang them with new hangers where the old ones are worn. I’ll tell you that on the estimate. A roofer should be willing to say “your gutters are fine.”

Gutters with the roof vs. later

SituationMy call
Straight, tight, no leaks, right sizeKeep and rehang
Sagging, loose hangers, leaking seamsReplace with the roof
Rotten fascia found at tear-offNew fascia, then new gutters
Hail-dented gutters and downspoutsReplace, usually on the claim with the roof
Overflow in heavy rainFix the downspouts and sizing, not just the gutter
New roof color clashesReplace in a matching color

Doing it later costs more because the gutter has to come off a finished roof edge, and a second crew works around new drip edge and shingles. Doing it together means one crew, one estimate and the parts at the eave installed in the right order.

What Flower Mound’s reroof permit means for you

The Town of Flower Mound requires a permit to replace or re-cover a roof, and the work has to meet the Town’s adopted codes (see the Town’s residential permit guidelines). We handle the permit on our roof jobs. If you’re in a neighborhood with an HOA, include the gutter color with the roof color on your approval request so there are no surprises.

What goes into a roof-and-gutter estimate

From my notes on how we price jobs: most jobs are tear-offs; trim is generally fascia and drip edge; and attic ventilation is usually included, because a roof needs proper ventilation to last. On an estimate that includes gutters, look for:

  1. Gutter size (5-inch or 6-inch) for each run
  2. Downspout size and count, including at valleys
  3. Seamless, and the color
  4. Fascia: how bad wood is handled
  5. New drip edge, and how the gutter ties in under it
  6. Where each downspout discharges

My post on how much a shingle roof replacement costs covers the roof side of the price. If you want a tougher roof above the new gutters, see Class 4 shingles in Flower Mound. And if the trim needs paint once the new gutters are up, we do exterior painting in Flower Mound too.

Get your roof and gutters checked together

An inspection usually takes 15 to 45 minutes, and you don’t need to be home unless there’s a leak inside. You get a free digital photo report showing the roof, the gutters, the downspouts and the fascia, and a free written estimate with the gutters priced as a separate line.

We’re certified with GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, Atlas, Johns Manville, Carlisle, Tropical Roofing Products, Mule-Hide and Enviroshake, and many other roof manufacturers. We’re fully insured, BBB A+ rated, with references available on request, and we have 5.0 stars on Google at all three offices: Bridgeport, Decatur and Rhome. Our workmanship warranty runs from 10 years up to lifetime, depending on the job.

Request your free estimate or call (817) 733-9228. You can also use the estimate form below.

Frequently asked questions

Should I replace gutters when replacing my roof?

Not always. If your gutters are straight, tight to the fascia, sized right and not leaking, we take them down carefully, put the roof on and rehang them. Replace them with the roof if they sag, leak at the seams, are dented by hail, overflow in hard rain, or if the fascia behind them is rotten. Doing both at once means the drip edge, fascia and gutter are tied together in the right order.

Do the gutters have to come off for a roof replacement?

Often, yes, at least in sections. The drip edge goes on at the eave, and the gutter has to sit under it so water drops into the gutter instead of behind it. Gutters that are taken down get rehung with new hangers where the old ones are worn.

Can the same crew do my roof and gutters?

Yes. We install seamless gutters and downspouts, and we also do soffit and fascia, painting and replacement windows. One estimate covers the roof and anything else on the house you want done.

Will insurance pay for my gutters after hail in Flower Mound?

If hail dented your gutters and downspouts, they are usually part of the claim along with the roof. Policies differ, so check yours. In Texas you generally have 1 year from the date of loss to file a claim. Our free digital photo report shows the gutter and downspout damage along with the roof.

Do I need bigger gutters if I switch to a metal roof?

Sometimes. Metal sheds water faster than shingles, so on long runs or below valleys we check the gutter size and the number of downspouts. Often adding a downspout or going to a larger outlet fixes overflow without changing the whole gutter.

Get a free roof inspection

We get on the roof, photograph what we find, and tell you plainly whether you need a repair or a replacement.

Get a free estimate

Tell us how to reach you. Blake or the team will call you back.

Or call (817) 733-9228 snowexteriors@gmail.com