Snow Roofing & Exteriors logo Call (817) 733-9228
Blog

Standing Seam vs. Enviroshake on a Westlake Modern Farmhouse: Look, Weight, Hail, Color and Using Both

By Blake Snow, owner ·

Modern farmhouse with white board-and-batten and limestone walls, a weathered gray shake-look roof on the main gables and black standing seam metal on the porch and garage
Illustration

The modern farmhouse is everywhere in Westlake now: white board-and-batten, limestone, black windows and steep gables. The roof is a big part of that look, and on a house like this it usually comes down to two choices. Standing seam metal for crisp vertical lines, or Enviroshake for the softer look of weathered cedar. On a lot of the best houses, the answer is both.

I’m Blake Snow. I’ve been roofing for 30 years. We form our own standing seam panels on our own roll formers, and I’m a certified Enviroshake installer and an Enviroshake representative, so you know where I stand. I’ll tell you plainly when standing seam is the better roof for your house.

The short version

Standing seam metalEnviroshake
LookCrisp vertical lines, modern, cleanWeathered cedar shake, soft texture and shadow lines
Best onBlack-and-white modern farmhouses, porches, low roofs, metal-forward designsStone and timber farmhouses, Hill Country and traditional looks
Material24- or 26-gauge steel panels, formed on siteComposite of 95% post-industrial recycled material, color all the way through
WeightAmong the lightest roofs you can buyAbout 260 lb per square (maker’s number)
Minimum pitchDepends on the panel: snap-lock generally 3:12 and up, some 2:12; mechanically seamed lower2:12 recommended minimum; separate low-slope guide under 3:12
HailCan dent in big hail; ask about the panel’s impact ratingUL 2218 Class 4 listed
FireNoncombustible metalClass A available (confirm it’s not the Class C product)
WindDepends on panel, clips and fasteningUp to 180 mph listed
Color over timeHolds its color (PVDF finishes best)Weathers in year one to a matte aged-cedar look, then holds it
SolarClamps to the seams, no roof penetrationsMounted with flashed attachments
WarrantyPaint finish warranty from the coil maker, plus our workmanship warranty25-year Standard or 50-year Gold (Gold needs Enviroshield underlayment); Factory Trained Installer and registration required

Enviroshake figures are from Enviroshake’s own published FAQs and warranty pages. Standing seam pitch limits come from each panel’s published data.

The look: lines vs. texture

Standing seam is the roof most modern farmhouses are drawn with. The vertical seams line up with board-and-batten and make tall gables look taller. Matte black or dark bronze over white siding is the classic combination, and it reads clean from the street. If the house is mostly white siding, black windows and simple gables, standing seam usually wins.

Enviroshake brings texture and shadow. It looks like cedar that has been on the house a few years, which pairs well with lots of limestone, stained timber, cedar posts and older live oaks. If the house leans more Hill Country or traditional than modern, Enviroshake often looks more at home.

Using both on one house

This is where a Westlake farmhouse really comes together. A common layout:

  • Enviroshake on the main roof for texture and warmth.
  • Standing seam on the front porch, bays, dormers, the garage connector and any low roofs. Porch roofs are usually too flat for shake, and a dark metal porch roof frames the front of the house.

Or flip it: standing seam on the main roof, with Enviroshake on a cupola, a garage or a pool house for a more relaxed look. Either way, the trick is the transitions. Where a shake roof meets a metal roof, you need proper flashing, the right underlayment under both, and drip edges and gutters in the same color family. See our standing seam accents on porches, bays and entries.

Weight and framing

Both are light compared with tile or slate. Enviroshake lists about 260 lb per square. Steel standing seam is lighter still. That matters on a new build (lighter framing) and on a reroof from tile (no extra load). If you’re changing a tile roof to either one, we check the framing and battens anyway, since old tile roofs often hide deck problems.

Hail in Westlake

NOAA’s Storm Events Database lists 53 reports of 1.75-inch (golf-ball) or larger hail within about 10 miles of Westlake from 2016 through May 2026. A few: 3-inch hail near the Roanoke airport on March 14, 2024, about 4 miles away; 2.5-inch hail in Roanoke on June 11, 2023, about 2 miles away; and 3.25-inch hail in Keller on April 28, 2021, about 4.5 miles away.

  • Enviroshake lists a UL 2218 Class 4 impact rating, and the maker says its products aren’t damaged by hail.
  • Standing seam steel can dent in large hail even when it still keeps water out. Ask about the panel’s impact rating, and ask your insurance agent in writing how your policy treats cosmetic damage to metal.

No roof is hail-proof. After a storm, get it inspected. In Texas you generally have 1 year from the date of loss to file a claim, but check your policy.

Color and how it ages

  • Standing seam: pick the color you want to live with. PVDF (Kynar 500) finishes generally hold color and gloss better than SMP. See PVDF vs. SMP and metal roof colors and finishes.
  • Enviroshake: the color changes once, on purpose. It weathers through its first year to a matte, aged-cedar look and then holds it. Look at a roof that’s a few years old, not just a new sample, before you choose.

On a mixed roof, pick the metal color after you’ve seen weathered Enviroshake, not the fresh sample.

Noise, heat and solar

  • Noise: on solid decking with underlayment, a standing seam roof isn’t the tin-barn drum people imagine. Enviroshake is quiet too.
  • Heat: lighter metal colors reflect more sun. Black looks great but runs hotter, so attic ventilation matters on either roof.
  • Solar: standing seam takes clamp-on mounts on the seams with no holes in the roof, a real plus if panels are in your plans.

Install details that matter

Standing seam: concealed clips that let panels move with heat, panels formed to the full length of each slope (no end laps), and the right panel for the pitch. We form ours on site, in 24 or 26 gauge, and our metal lead time is typically 1 to 2 weeks. More: standing seam in Westlake.

Enviroshake: at least a 3/8-inch gap between pieces, four nails per piece (Enviroshake recommends 1 1/2-inch stainless ring-shank), Enviroshield underlayment for the 50-year Gold warranty, and a Factory Trained Installer with the roof registered. More: Enviroshake in Westlake.

Westlake permit and HOA

The Town of Westlake says every reroof needs a permit, submitted online with a site plan, the roofing material and an official HOA approval letter. So HOA approval comes first. For Enviroshake, bring samples, product sheets and photos of weathered roofs. For standing seam, bring the panel profile, seam height and a color chip. Our guide: HOA approval for an Enviroshake roof. We pull the permit.

12 questions to ask before you sign

  1. Which parts of my house get standing seam, which get Enviroshake, and why?
  2. What’s the pitch of each roof, and is each product rated for it?
  3. Snap-lock or mechanically seamed, and what gauge?
  4. Who forms the metal panels, and are they full length?
  5. PVDF or SMP finish, and what color do you recommend next to weathered Enviroshake?
  6. Is the Enviroshake Class A or Class C?
  7. Are you an Enviroshake Factory Trained Installer, and will you register the roof?
  8. Which underlayment goes under each roof, by name?
  9. How do you flash where the two roofs meet?
  10. What do the gutters, drip edge and trim look like on each roof?
  11. Who handles the HOA packet and the Westlake permit?
  12. What’s your workmanship warranty, in writing? (Ours runs from 10 years up to lifetime, depending on the job.)

Talk to us about your Westlake farmhouse roof

We install standing seam and Enviroshake in Westlake, Southlake, Trophy Club, Keller and Roanoke, on new builds and reroofs. Every roof is installed to manufacturer specs by certified installers. We’re certified with GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, Atlas, Johns Manville, Carlisle, Tropical Roofing Products, Mule-Hide and Enviroshake, and many other roof manufacturers. We’re BBB A+ rated, with 5.0 stars on Google at all three offices: Bridgeport, Decatur and Rhome. Request a free estimate or call (817) 733-9228.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Is standing seam or Enviroshake better for a modern farmhouse?

It depends on the look you want. Standing seam gives the crisp, vertical lines most modern farmhouses are drawn with, especially in black or dark bronze over white board-and-batten. Enviroshake gives a softer, weathered cedar look that suits farmhouses with more stone, timber and a traditional or Hill Country feel. Many of the best houses use both: Enviroshake on the main roof and standing seam on porches, bays and low roofs.

How low a pitch can each roof go on?

Enviroshake lists 2:12 as its recommended minimum, with a separate low-slope guide under 3:12. Standing seam depends on the panel: snap-lock panels are generally made for 3:12 and steeper, some down to 2:12, and mechanically seamed panels go lower. The International Building Code's floor for standing seam systems is 1/4:12. Very low porch roofs are usually standing seam.

Which is better in hail?

Enviroshake lists a UL 2218 Class 4 impact rating. Standing seam steel can dent in large hail even when it doesn't leak, so ask about the panel's impact rating and the cosmetic-damage language in your insurance policy. No roof is hail-proof. Near Westlake, NOAA records show 53 reports of 1.75-inch or larger hail within about 10 miles from 2016 through May 2026.

Does Enviroshake fade?

It's designed to change once. Enviroshake says its color-through composite weathers in its first year to a matte, aged cedar look and then holds that look. Standing seam paint finishes are made to hold their color, and PVDF finishes generally hold color and gloss better than SMP.

Do I need a permit to re-roof in Westlake?

Yes. The Town of Westlake says every reroof needs a permit through its online system with a site plan, the roofing material and an official HOA approval letter. Get the HOA letter first. We pull the permit.

Can you install both?

Yes. We form our standing seam panels on our own roll formers, and Blake Snow is a certified Enviroshake installer and Enviroshake representative. Enviroshake's warranty requires a Factory Trained Installer and a registered roof.

Get a free roof inspection

We get on the roof, photograph what we find, and tell you plainly whether you need a repair or a replacement.

Get a free estimate

Tell us how to reach you. Blake or the team will call you back.

Or call (817) 733-9228