What a core cut shows
| Question | What the core tells us | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| How many roofs are on there? | Each membrane layer is visible in the sample | Under the 2021 IBC reroofing rules (Section 1512), a new roof generally can't be laid over an existing roof that is water-soaked or deteriorated, or over one that already has two or more layers. |
| Is the insulation wet? | Wet or dry, by look, feel and meter | Wet insulation has to come out before a coating or recover |
| What insulation, and how thick? | Type and thickness of each layer | Energy code, tapered design and fastener length |
| What deck? | Steel, wood, concrete, gypsum or lightweight fill | Fastener type, pull-test plan and attachment method |
| What membrane? | Built-up, mod bit, single-ply or coating | Compatibility with a coating or new system |
Every core is patched the same day. On older built-up roofs, samples can also go to a lab for asbestos testing when the owner or regulations require it.
How a fastener pull test works
The industry field procedure is ANSI/SPRI FX-1. In plain English:
- The roofing and insulation are removed down to the deck at each test spot; a core cutter is the usual tool
- The fastener is installed the same way it will be on the job: same fastener, same depth, same tools
- A calibrated gauge pulls it straight out, and the force is recorded
- FX-1 calls for at least 10 pulls on a roof up to 50,000 sq ft, plus 5 more for each additional 50,000 sq ft, with half of them at the corners and perimeter
- Each roof area with a different deck, elevation or assembly is tested separately, and every test is marked on a roof plan
Pull-test procedures vary by manufacturer, and the manufacturer generally sends a rep to meet us on site for the pull test. The manufacturer and the wind-uplift design use those numbers to set the fastener type and spacing. Low values can mean a different fastener, tighter spacing, an adhered system, or deck repairs before the new roof goes on.
Adhesion tests before a coating
Adhesion-test procedures also vary by manufacturer. A typical field test applies a small patch of coating to the cleaned roof, lets it cure, and pulls it. That shows whether the coating will bond to that surface as cleaned and primed, or whether a different primer or prep is needed. The manufacturer generally sends a rep to meet us on site for the adhesion test. See the silicone, acrylic and urethane spec guides and commercial roof coatings.
Why tests matter for warranties
Manufacturers want to know what's under their system. Pull-test results, a moisture survey and core findings are often part of the paperwork for a recover or a long-term warranty. Both 10-year and 20-year manufacturer NDL (no-dollar-limit) warranties are available on commercial jobs. The price depends on which term you choose, and the manufacturer issues an NDL warranty only after its own inspection. Read NDL vs. material vs. workmanship warranties and how a roof qualifies for a 20-year NDL.
Finding where to cut
We walk the roof, fly a drone for photos of areas that are hard to reach safely, and run drone thermal (infrared) scans that help show where water has gotten under the surface. The thermal scan tells us where to core, so a few cuts confirm what the whole roof is doing. See infrared leak detection. Every inspection comes with a free digital photo report, so you see what we see.
Ask every bidder
- How many cores, and where? Will they be patched the same day?
- Will fasteners be pull-tested to the manufacturer's procedure, with a manufacturer rep on site, before the attachment is chosen?
- For a coating: has an adhesion test been done on this roof with a manufacturer rep?
- Will the results be on a roof plan you keep?
Code sections and test standards are summarized in plain English from the published documents. Your building official, the manufacturer's current specification and the warranty document have the final word.
We're certified with GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, Atlas, Johns Manville, Carlisle, Tropical Roofing Products, Mule-Hide and Enviroshake, and many other roof manufacturers. We offer same-day response in almost every case, and we answer leak and storm calls 24/7 at (817) 733-9228.
Commercial warranty: a workmanship warranty from 10 years up to lifetime, depending on the job, plus both 10-year and 20-year NDL (no-dollar-limit) manufacturer warranties (the price depends on which NDL term you choose). Manufacturer coverage depends on the product and brand, and on the project qualifying for that manufacturer's program. We put the exact warranty for your roof in writing.
Certified, with 30 years installing every major roofing brand, a family roofing business going back 75 years, and over $80 million in completed roofing projects. 5.0 stars on Google at all three of our offices.
Request a free inspection or call (817) 733-9228. Small repairs are welcome too.
