Snow Roofing & Exteriors logo Call (817) 733-9228
Blog

Carlisle Sure-Flex KEE HP vs. FleeceBACK KEE HP in Fort Worth: Which PVC Sheet Fits Your Commercial Roof?

By Blake Snow, owner ·

Illustration of a roofing crew rolling out a new white single-ply membrane on a commercial roof
Illustration

Brands in this article

  • Carlisle logo

Fort Worth has a lot of roofs where PVC earns its keep: restaurants with grease exhaust, food processing and warehouse space up the I-35W corridor, retail strips with rooftop units every few feet, and older buildings near downtown and the Near Southside that still have built-up roofs under them. When an owner or property manager narrows a bid down to Carlisle PVC, the next question is usually the one nobody explains well: smooth Sure-Flex KEE HP, or FleeceBACK KEE HP?

I’m Blake Snow. I’ve been in roofing for 30 years, and we’re certified with Carlisle. This post compares Carlisle’s two KEE HP sheets using Carlisle’s own published data, then tells you which one I’d put on which kind of Fort Worth building and why. If you’re comparing Carlisle’s TPO instead, read my Carlisle Sure-Weld TPO post.

The short answer

  • Tearing off to the deck and putting down new insulation and cover board? Smooth Sure-Flex KEE HP is usually the simpler, lighter choice.
  • Going over rough concrete, or over a dry existing asphalt roof that’s allowed to stay, or want a fully adhered roof set in foam adhesive? FleeceBACK KEE HP is usually the better sheet.
  • Either way, you’re getting the same family of membrane: PVC made with Elvaloy KEE HP, polyester reinforcement, and hot-air-welded seams. The difference is the back of the sheet, and that changes how it attaches, what it can go over, and how tough it is underfoot.

What KEE HP actually is (and why it’s not TPO)

Carlisle’s Sure-Flex KEE HP data sheet says the membrane is made with Elvaloy KEE HP resin modifier. Carlisle says KEE HP’s higher molecular weight means slower migration than standard KEE, which gives it extended low- and high-temperature limits, more chemical resistance and better resistance to microbial growth.

In plain English: PVC needs something to keep it flexible. Cheaper PVC uses liquid plasticizers that can slowly leave the sheet. KEE HP is a solid modifier that Carlisle says won’t migrate out over time, so the membrane stays pliable and weldable as it ages. That matters on a 20-year roof, because the roof you patch in year 15 has to still take a weld.

It is not TPO. Carlisle’s TPO is Sure-Weld. PVC with KEE HP is what I usually point restaurants and buildings with oil, grease or chemical exhaust toward. Carlisle’s FleeceBACK KEE HP data sheet specifically lists resistance to acids, restaurant oils, fats and greases.

Side by side: Carlisle’s published numbers

Sure-Flex KEE HP (smooth)FleeceBACK KEE HP
Back of the sheetSmoothPolyester fleece
Thickness50, 60 or 80 mil105, 115 or 135 mil total (50, 60 or 80 mil over the fleece)
ColorsWhite, gray, tan, light grayWhite, gray, light gray, tan
StandardASTM D4434, Type III and/or Type IVASTM D4434
Impact ratingUL 2218 Class 4UL 2218 Class 4
Breaking strength (MD x CD)290 x 290 lbf (50 mil) to 330 x 320 lbf (80 mil)410 x 360 lbf (105 mil) to 500 x 490 lbf (135 mil)
Dynamic puncturePass (ASTM minimum 20 J)32.5 J (105) / 40 J (115) / 42.5 J (135)
AttachmentFully adhered, mechanically fastened, induction-weldedMechanically fastened, or adhered with low-rise foam, water-based or other approved adhesives
Wind uplift notePer specCarlisle lists ratings up to FM 1-990
White reflectance (CRRC)0.87 initial / 0.71 after 3 years, SRI 110 initialWhite and light gray are Title 24 compliant

Sources: Carlisle’s Sure-Flex KEE HP and FleeceBACK KEE HP product data sheets. Carlisle notes typical values are a guide, not guaranteed for every sample.

FleeceBACK roll sizes from Carlisle: 105 mil comes 10’ x 100’, 115 mil comes 5’ x 100’ or 10’ x 100’, and 135 mil comes 10’ x 75’. Carlisle says the 10’-wide sheets have 67% fewer seams than a modified bitumen system of the same size when used as a cap sheet.

Why the fleece matters on a Fort Worth roof

The fleece isn’t decoration. Carlisle’s data sheet says it does three jobs:

  1. Puncture resistance. It adds to the toughness of the sheet. Look at the dynamic puncture numbers above: every FleeceBACK thickness tests well above the ASTM minimum. On a roof where HVAC techs, sign crews and delivery people walk every week, that helps.
  2. A built-in separation layer. PVC and asphalt don’t get along. Carlisle says the fleece gives a built-in separation layer against rough concrete decks or existing asphalt-based roofing. That’s why FleeceBACK is the usual pick when an old built-up or mod-bit roof is allowed to stay in place.
  3. A mechanical bond to the adhesive. When FleeceBACK is set into Carlisle’s Flexible FAST low-rise foam adhesive, the foam grabs the fleece. Carlisle credits that bond for its wind uplift ratings up to FM 1-990. Foam adhesive also forgives small surface bumps that would telegraph through a smooth sheet.

Recover over an old built-up roof: when it’s allowed

A lot of older Fort Worth commercial buildings have a gravel or smooth built-up roof under them. Owners want to know if they can skip the tear-off. Sometimes, yes. But:

  • The old roof has to be dry. The building code’s reroofing rules don’t allow a recover over wet or deteriorated roofing, and no manufacturer will warrant a new sheet over soaked insulation. We check moisture with a meter and core cuts, and our FAA-certified drone pilot can fly the roof for a full overview first. See our drone roof inspection page.
  • There can’t already be too many layers. The code limits how many roofs can be stacked on a building. If there’s already a recover up there, it’s tear-off time.
  • Gravel has to come off. Loose gravel and a smooth new sheet don’t mix.

If a recover is allowed, FleeceBACK KEE HP, adhered per Carlisle’s recover spec, is usually how I’d do it. If a recover isn’t allowed, we tear off and you can use either sheet.

Hail and warranty: what Carlisle actually requires

Both data sheets list UL 2218 Class 4. That’s a lab impact rating. It is not the same as warranty hail coverage.

Carlisle’s mechanically fastened and adhered system specification spells out what earns hail coverage on Sure-Flex PVC and KEE HP:

  • 1-inch hail coverage: at least 60-mil PVC or KEE HP, adhered to an approved cover board
  • 2-inch hail coverage: 80-mil PVC or KEE HP, adhered to an approved cover board

So if hail coverage matters to you or your lender, the attachment method and the cover board matter as much as the sheet. A mechanically fastened roof straight over insulation won’t get there.

On warranty length, Carlisle’s tables show 5-, 10- or 15-year terms starting at 50 mil, 20 years at 60 mil, and up to 30 years on 80-mil KEE HP with the right system and details. On our commercial bids we offer 10-year and 20-year NDL (No Dollar Limit) warranty options at different prices, and we spell out the membrane, thickness and attachment behind each one. Our own workmanship warranty runs from 10 years up to lifetime, depending on the job.

Which sheet I’d use, building by building

Your Fort Worth buildingWhat I’d usually specWhy
Restaurant or food business with grease exhaustSure-Flex KEE HP 60 or 80 mil on a tear-off, or FleeceBACK KEE HP on a recoverKEE HP’s listed resistance to oils, fats and greases
Warehouse, full tear-off, new polyiso and cover boardSure-Flex KEE HP, mechanically fastened or induction-weldedLighter sheet, quick install, more widths
Older building with a dry built-up roof that’s allowed to stayFleeceBACK KEE HP, adheredFleece separates PVC from the old asphalt
Structural concrete deckFleeceBACK KEE HP, adheredFleece handles the rough surface
Heavy rooftop traffic (lots of HVAC, signs, antennas)FleeceBACK KEE HP 115 or 135, plus walkway padsHigher puncture numbers
Owner wants 2-inch hail coverage in the warranty80-mil KEE HP adhered to an approved cover boardCarlisle’s stated hail requirement

These are starting points. The deck, the existing roof, the wind zone and your budget decide the final spec.

What to ask before you sign a Carlisle PVC bid

  1. Is it Sure-Flex KEE HP or FleeceBACK KEE HP, and what thickness?
  2. Is it standard Sure-Flex PVC or KEE HP? They’re different sheets.
  3. How is it attached: mechanically fastened, induction-welded, or adhered (and with what adhesive)?
  4. Is there a cover board? Which one?
  5. Is this a tear-off or a recover? If recover, what did the moisture survey show?
  6. What warranty term, and is it NDL?
  7. Does the warranty include hail coverage? What size hail?
  8. Who repairs the metal edge and coping, and is it part of the warranty?
  9. How are walkways and rooftop unit service paths handled?
  10. Who pulls the permit, and who schedules the inspection?

After a storm

Get the roof inspected and documented before anyone patches it, and keep vendors off damaged areas. Our commercial hail claims page covers what to photograph and record. In Texas you generally have 1 year from the date of loss to file a claim, but check your policy.

Talk to us about a Carlisle PVC roof in Fort Worth

We install Carlisle PVC, TPO and other low-slope systems on commercial buildings across Fort Worth, Haltom City, North Richland Hills, Saginaw, White Settlement and Benbrook. We’re certified with GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, Atlas, Johns Manville, Carlisle, Tropical Roofing Products, Mule-Hide and Enviroshake, and many other roof manufacturers. We’re fully insured, BBB A+ rated, and references are available on request.

See our Fort Worth commercial roofing and PVC roofing pages, use the estimate form below, or call (817) 733-9228.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Carlisle Sure-Flex KEE HP and FleeceBACK KEE HP?

Both are polyester-reinforced PVC membranes made with Elvaloy KEE HP, and both are heat-welded at the seams. Sure-Flex KEE HP is a smooth-backed sheet in 50, 60 and 80 mil. FleeceBACK KEE HP is the same kind of KEE HP membrane with a polyester fleece bonded to the back, sold as 105, 115 and 135 mil total sheets (50, 60 and 80 mil of membrane over the fleece). The fleece adds puncture resistance and acts as a built-in separation layer over rough concrete or old asphalt roofs.

When does FleeceBACK KEE HP make more sense than smooth Sure-Flex KEE HP?

Usually when the roof is going over a rough or asphalt-based surface, like a structural concrete deck or an existing built-up or modified bitumen roof that is dry and allowed to stay, when you want a fully adhered roof set in low-rise foam adhesive for wind uplift, or when the roof sees heavy foot traffic and you want extra puncture resistance. Carlisle lists wind uplift ratings up to FM 1-990 for FleeceBACK KEE HP.

When is smooth Sure-Flex KEE HP the better choice?

On a complete tear-off over new insulation and cover board, smooth Sure-Flex KEE HP is often the simpler, lighter sheet. It can be mechanically fastened, induction-welded or fully adhered, and it comes in more widths. It also runs a little thinner, so details and flashings go quickly.

Is Carlisle KEE HP a TPO?

No. KEE HP is PVC (polyvinyl chloride) with Elvaloy KEE HP as a solid plasticizer. Carlisle's TPO line is Sure-Weld, which is a different chemistry. PVC with KEE HP is often chosen for restaurants and buildings with grease, oil or chemical exhaust on the roof.

Are Carlisle KEE HP membranes hail rated?

Carlisle's data sheets list a UL 2218 Class 4 impact rating for both Sure-Flex KEE HP and FleeceBACK KEE HP. For warranty hail coverage, Carlisle's specification says 1-inch hail coverage needs at least 60-mil PVC or KEE HP adhered to an approved cover board, and 2-inch hail coverage needs 80-mil adhered to cover board. A lab impact rating is not a warranty promise, so get the hail coverage in writing.

How long can a Carlisle KEE HP warranty run?

Carlisle's specification tables show 5- to 20-year terms on 50- and 60-mil sheets and up to 30 years on 80-mil KEE HP with the right system and details. On our commercial bids we offer 10-year and 20-year NDL (No Dollar Limit) warranty options at different prices, and our workmanship warranty runs from 10 years up to lifetime, depending on the job.

Hail hit our Fort Worth building. How long do we have to file a claim?

In Texas it's generally 1 year from the date of loss, but check your policy, since commercial policies vary. Get the roof inspected and documented before anyone patches it.

Get a free roof inspection

We get on the roof, photograph what we find, and tell you plainly whether you need a repair or a replacement.

Get a free estimate

Tell us how to reach you. Blake or the team will call you back.

Or call (817) 733-9228