Snow Roofing & Exteriors logo Call (817) 733-9228
Commercial roofs · Coat or replace?

Roof Coating vs Replacement

Roof coating vs replacement comes down to one question: is what's under the surface still dry and sound? If it is, a coating can add years for a fraction of the disruption of a tear-off. If it isn't, a coating just seals wet insulation in. Snow Roofing & Exteriors tests before we recommend either, and prices both when both are honest options.
  • TPO, PVC, modified bitumen, metal and coatings
  • Repairs, restorations and new roofs
  • 10- and 20-year NDL warranties available
  • American WeatherStar Approved Contractor
Illustration of a flat commercial roof half coated bright white next to the old gray surface
Illustration

The quick answer

ConditionCoatingReplacement
Insulation dry, membrane aging but intactGood fitUsually more than you need
Small wet areasFit after wet areas are cut out and replacedOption if the roof is near end of life anyway
Wet insulation across much of the roofNoReplace
Metal roof with sound panels, failing screwsRe-screw and coatOnly if panels are rusted through
Deck damage, sagging, or structural issuesNoReplace and repair the deck

How we test before we recommend

  1. Walk and drone the roof. We walk the roof, fly a drone for photos of areas that are hard to reach safely, and run drone thermal (infrared) scans that help show where water has gotten under the surface.
  2. Core cuts to see the layers and whether the insulation is wet. See pull tests and core cuts.
  3. Adhesion test of the coating on your actual roof surface, usually with the manufacturer's rep on site
  4. Photo report. Every inspection comes with a free digital photo report, so you see what we see.

Under the 2021 IBC reroofing rules (Section 1512), a new roof generally can't be laid over an existing roof that is water-soaked or deteriorated, or over one that already has two or more layers. A moisture survey and a core cut tell us which applies. A coating has to go over a sound, dry roof to work.

Which coating?

Silicone handles ponding water best and is common on Texas flat roofs. Acrylic is economical on roofs that drain well and on metal. Urethane takes foot traffic and impact. We have hands-on experience with coating systems from American WeatherStar (we're an American WeatherStar Approved Contractor), Carlisle and Tropical Roofing Products, plus EpoxyFlex, our own private-label coating, and we apply every major brand.

When replacement is the honest answer

  • Wet insulation across large areas
  • Deck rust or rot, or a roof that sags between joists
  • Repeated leaks at details a coating can't rebuild (parapets, curbs, edge metal)
  • You need a warranty term a coating system on your roof can't qualify for

Replacement options: TPO, PVC, modified bitumen, built-up, or a metal retrofit. See multi-option bids to compare them on one page.

Warranties

Both 10-year and 20-year manufacturer NDL (no-dollar-limit) warranties are available on commercial jobs. The price depends on which term you choose, and the manufacturer issues an NDL warranty only after its own inspection. Coating warranty terms depend on the system and the thickness applied, and we spell them out in the proposal. Our workmanship warranty runs from 10 years up to lifetime, depending on the job.

We're certified with GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, Atlas, Johns Manville, Carlisle, Tropical Roofing Products, Mule-Hide and Enviroshake, and many other roof manufacturers. We offer same-day response in almost every case, and we answer leak and storm calls 24/7 at (817) 733-9228.

Code sections and standards are summarized in plain English from the published documents. Your building official, the manufacturer's current specification and the warranty document have the final word.

Commercial warranty: a workmanship warranty from 10 years up to lifetime, depending on the job, plus both 10-year and 20-year NDL (no-dollar-limit) manufacturer warranties (the price depends on which NDL term you choose). Manufacturer coverage depends on the product and brand, and on the project qualifying for that manufacturer's program. We put the exact warranty for your roof in writing.

Certified, with 30 years installing every major roofing brand, a family roofing business going back 75 years, and over $80 million in completed roofing projects. 5.0 stars on Google at all three of our offices.

Request a free inspection or call (817) 733-9228. Small repairs are welcome too.

Frequently asked questions

Is a roof coating cheaper than a replacement?

Usually, because there is no tear-off or new insulation. It only makes sense if the roof underneath is sound and the insulation is dry.

Can you coat over wet insulation?

No. Wet areas have to be cut out and replaced first, or the roof should be replaced.

How do you know if the insulation is wet?

Drone thermal scans show likely wet areas, and core cuts confirm what is under the surface.

Can you coat a metal roof?

Yes, after re-screwing and treating rust, if the panels are sound.

Do coatings come with warranties?

Yes. Terms depend on the system and thickness applied, and we spell them out in the proposal.

Which manufacturers are you certified with?

We are certified with GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, Atlas, Johns Manville, Carlisle, Tropical Roofing Products, Mule-Hide and Enviroshake, and many other roof manufacturers.

Get a free estimate

Tell us how to reach you. Blake or the team will call you back.

Or call (817) 733-9228