Snow Roofing & Exteriors logo Call (817) 733-9228
Blog

Historic Slate Reroofs in Highland Park and University Park: Reviews, Like-Kind Slate and Staging

By Blake Snow, owner ·

Illustration of a brick Tudor estate home with a multicolor natural slate roof, tall brick chimneys and half-timbered gables
Illustration

Historic slate reroofs in Highland Park and University Park are some of the most rewarding jobs in North Texas, and some of the easiest to get wrong. Many of these homes were built in the 1920s and 1930s, with Tudor, Georgian and French-inspired rooflines that depend on the slate for their character. Get the slate, the flashing or the job-site plan wrong, and you lose something that took a century to earn.

I’m Blake Snow. I’ve been roofing for 30 years, I’m the third generation in a family business that goes back 75 years, and our crews have completed over $80 million in roofing projects. We install and repair natural slate across Highland Park, University Park and the rest of Dallas. Here’s how I plan a historic slate reroof in the Park Cities, from who reviews it to where the dumpster goes.

The short version

  • There’s no town historic review board in Highland Park or University Park, but you still need a permit, and some houses carry state or tax-credit obligations.
  • Repair before you replace. Many old slate roofs fail because of rusted nails and worn flashing, not worn-out stone.
  • Like-kind slate matches size, shape, color, texture, exposure and coursing. Document all six before anything comes off.
  • Salvage sound slate and keep it for the sections that stay and for future repairs.
  • Copper flashing goes with a slate roof meant to last generations.
  • Staging is half the job on a tight Park Cities lot: dumpster placement, deliveries, neighbors, and closing up the roof every day.

Who actually reviews a historic slate reroof in the Park Cities?

Many roofers talk about “historic review” in the Park Cities. Here’s what the official sources say:

WhoDo they review a slate reroof?Source
Town of Highland ParkNo preservation review. The town says it “does not have local ordinances, districts, etc. imposing restrictions or requirements on property owners.” Permits are still required for repairs and remodeling.Town of Highland Park FAQ, Community Development
City of University ParkNo historic preservation ordinance, as reported by People Newspapers. Roofing requires a permit.University Park new resident packet
Preservation Park CitiesRecognition only. It keeps the inventory of designated homes and awards plaques. It has no legal review power.Preservation Park Cities
Texas Historical CommissionOnly if the house is a Recorded Texas Historic Landmark. Then 60 days’ written notice is required before changes to its exterior integrity.THC RTHL review
National Park ServiceNational Register listing by itself places no restrictions on a non-federal owner, unless the project involves federal assistance.NPS National Register FAQ
City of Dallas Landmark CommissionOnly for homes inside the City of Dallas in a Landmark District or individually listed as a Dallas Landmark. A Certificate of Appropriateness is required before exterior work.Dallas Landmark Review Process

So for most Highland Park and University Park homes, the reviewers are the building department and you. A few situations change that:

  • Recorded Texas Historic Landmark. If your house has a Texas historical medallion as an RTHL, notify the THC in writing at least 60 days before work that could change its historic or architectural integrity, with drawings and photos. Normal maintenance and repair is exempt. Like-kind slate makes for a simple review. A switch to a different-looking material may not.
  • Tax credits or grants. If you’re using federal or state rehabilitation tax credits or a preservation grant, the roof has to meet the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards. Ask your preservation consultant before you choose a material.
  • Deed restrictions or easements. Some owners have added preservation deed restrictions or easements. Check your title documents.
  • Next door in Dallas. A home in a Dallas Landmark District goes through the city’s Certificate of Appropriateness process. Dallas lists replacing deteriorated features like roofing as routine maintenance that staff can approve. Bigger changes go to the Landmark Commission.

No review board doesn’t mean anything goes. The roof is often the single most visible feature of a 1920s Park Cities house. Swapping natural slate for something that doesn’t look like slate is legal in both towns, but it changes the house for good. If the weight or cost of natural slate is the issue, read synthetic vs. real slate or our Highland Park synthetic slate page first.

Repair, reslate or replace?

The National Park Service’s Preservation Brief 29 on historic slate roofs is clear: slate roofs should be repaired rather than replaced whenever possible, and installed properly they can last 60 to 125 years or longer. Many old Park Cities slate roofs that leak have sound stone held on by rusting nails, with worn flashing at chimneys, valleys and dormers.

I cover the decision in detail in natural slate roof repair vs. replacement. In short:

What we findWhat I usually recommend
Sound slate, a few broken piecesRepair: replace the broken slates with matching slate
Sound slate, failed flashingReflash: lift slate at chimneys, valleys and walls, install new copper flashing, relay the slate
Sound slate, failed nails or underlaymentStrip, salvage and relay: take the slate off, sort and sound it, then relay it with new nails and underlayment, adding matched slate to make up the loss
Slate flaking, soft or delaminating across the roofReplace with new like-kind slate, keeping sound salvaged pieces for repairs

See our slate repair page for the repair side.

Like-kind materials: matching the original slate

Preservation Brief 29 says size, shape, color, texture, exposure and coursing are among the most important characteristics to document and match. Here’s what I record before anything comes off:

CharacteristicWhat we documentWhy it matters
SizeLength and width of the field slates, and any graduated sizesGraduated roofs step from larger slate at the eave to smaller at the ridge
ShapeSquare-cut, clipped corners, fishscale or other patternsPatterned bands are part of the design
ColorOriginal color and weathered color, by sectionSome slates weather to a different shade over time
Texture and thicknessStandard, textural or heavy slateThick, rough slate reads very differently from thin, even slate
ExposureInches of each slate showingChanging exposure changes the look of every course
CoursingStraight, staggered or random-width coursesRandom widths and mixed colors are hard to replicate without planning

The brief also points to old photos, shadow lines and nail-hole patterns on the deck, and leftover pieces in the eaves as clues to the original roof. On a Park Cities house, old photos from the owner, the family or a preservation inventory can help.

Then we match the stone. The brief notes that mottled gray Vermont slate is the closest match available today for old Pennsylvania ribbon slate, and that imported slate often doesn’t match the colors and textures of U.S. slate. That’s why I bring samples to the house and compare them in daylight against the actual roof, not a catalog. Learn more about the stone on our slate quarries and brands, Vermont and New York slate and Pennsylvania slate pages, and about specifying grade and thickness in slate grade, thickness and ASTM C406.

Salvaging and sorting the old slate

When nails or flashing caused the failure, much of the slate can usually be saved. Preservation Brief 29 says each salvaged slate must be sounded for cracks, faults and weathering. A sound slate gives a clear ring when tapped. A dull thud means a hidden crack or soft stone. We sort salvaged slate by size and color on pallets, keep the best pieces for the most visible slopes, and set aside extras for future repairs.

Flashing and fastening

A slate roof is only as good as its metal. On historic slate I use copper for valleys, step and counterflashing, chimney flashing, crickets and gutters, so the metal lasts about as long as the stone. More in copper flashing for valleys and gutters on slate and tile and our copper roofing page. Fastening (copper nails, hooks, nail gauge and length) is its own topic, covered in slate hooks vs. copper nails in Highland Park.

The deck and framing

Preservation Brief 29 recommends replacing rotted sheathing as the slate comes off and checking the roof framing for deflection, cracking or twisting. If we find structural problems, we bring in a structural engineer experienced with older buildings. The brief also says to finish other roof-level work, like chimney repointing, before the new slate goes on. That’s the right time to fix a leaning chimney or add a cricket behind a wide one.

Staging a slate reroof on a tight Park Cities lot

Park Cities lots are tight, with mature trees, alleys and neighbors close by. Both towns have rules for job sites:

  • Working hours. Highland Park allows construction Monday through Saturday, 7 a.m. to 6 p.m., with no work on Sundays or listed holidays, per its Community Development page. University Park’s job site rules list the same hours.
  • Dumpsters. Highland Park requires construction waste haulers to be franchised with the town, per its Forms and Applications page. University Park’s job site rules also call for franchised dumpsters.
  • Deliveries and parking. University Park’s rules address blocking lanes, rutting the parkway, mud on the pavement, and blocking alleys and driveways, plus worker parking.
  • Neighbors. University Park’s rules call for notifying neighbors before work starts.

Here’s how we stage a historic slate reroof:

  1. Walk the site with you before we bid: where the slate pallets, dumpster and lift can go, and which trees, beds and hardscape need protection.
  2. Protect the house and grounds with tarps, plywood over walks and beds, and catch netting where slate comes down near windows.
  3. Strip in sections. Preservation Brief 29 recommends stripping in sections and installing underlayment as you go, so the whole roof is never open to the weather. We close up every section before we leave each day.
  4. Lower slate, don’t throw it. Salvageable slate comes down by hand or lift to be sorted, not down a chute.
  5. Keep the alley open. Deliveries are timed so trucks don’t block neighbors.
  6. Clean up daily with magnets for nails and a walk of the yard, beds and street.

Hail and Park Cities slate

Natural slate can crack in hail and under foot traffic. NOAA lists 10 reports of hail 1.75 inches or larger within about 10 miles of Highland Park from 2016 through September 2026, the largest 2.5-inch hail on June 2, 2017, according to its Storm Events Database. After a storm, we inspect slate from ladders and roof hooks, not by walking across it, and give you a digital photo report. If you file a claim, Texas generally gives you 1 year from the date of loss; check your policy. Our storm damage page explains how inspections and claims work.

Historic slate reroof checklist

Before you sign, ask these questions:

  1. Can my roof be repaired or reflashed instead of replaced?
  2. Is my house a Recorded Texas Historic Landmark, or under tax credits, a grant, an easement or deed restrictions?
  3. Will you document size, shape, color, texture, exposure and coursing before tear-off?
  4. Which quarry and color are you proposing, and can I see samples against my roof?
  5. How much of my old slate will you salvage, and where will you store the extras?
  6. Will the flashing be copper, and which details are being replaced?
  7. What nails or hooks will you use?
  8. How will you check the deck and framing?
  9. Will the chimneys be repointed before the slate goes back on?
  10. Who pulls the permit, and are you registered with the town or city?
  11. Where will the dumpster, slate pallets and lift go, and how will you protect my trees and beds?
  12. How will you close up the roof every night?
  13. What’s the written schedule?
  14. What’s the workmanship warranty, in writing?

Areas we serve

We repair and install natural slate in Highland Park, University Park, Preston Hollow and across Dallas. We also work on clay tile in Highland Park and University Park, and on the complex rooflines these homes are known for. See slate, copper turrets and mansards.

Let’s look at your slate roof

We’re certified with GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, Atlas, Johns Manville, Carlisle, Tropical Roofing Products, Mule-Hide and Enviroshake, and many other roof manufacturers. Snow Roofing & Exteriors is fully insured, has offices in Bridgeport, Decatur and Rhome, is BBB A+ rated, and has 5.0 stars on Google at all three offices: Bridgeport, Decatur and Rhome. References are available on request. Our workmanship warranty runs from 10 years up to lifetime, depending on the job.

Call (817) 733-9228 or request an estimate. I’ll walk the roof with you and give you a free digital photo report and a written plan for repairing, reslating or replacing your slate with like-kind stone.

Frequently asked questions

Does Highland Park or University Park have a historic review board for roofs?

No. The Town of Highland Park says it does not have local ordinances or districts imposing preservation restrictions on property owners, and neither Highland Park nor University Park has a historic preservation ordinance. You still need a building permit from the town or city, and you should check any deed restrictions, a Recorded Texas Historic Landmark designation, or federal or state tax credit or grant terms tied to the house.

My house has a Preservation Park Cities plaque. Does that limit my reroof?

Not legally. The Town of Highland Park points owners to Preservation Park Cities for its inventory of designated properties, and that designation is recognition, not an ordinance. Many owners with a plaque still choose like-kind slate because the roof is a big part of what earned the plaque.

What if my house is a Recorded Texas Historic Landmark?

Then the Texas Historical Commission must be notified in writing at least 60 days before work that could change the building's historical or architectural integrity, under Texas Government Code 442.006(f). Normal maintenance and repair is exempt. The THC reviews against the Secretary of the Interior's Standards and says its reviews take no more than 30 days once it has the project documents. Replacing slate with a different-looking roof is the kind of change that needs notice.

Does National Register listing stop me from changing my roof?

No. The National Park Service says listing places no restrictions on what a non-federal owner does with the property unless the project involves federal assistance, such as funding or licensing. Federal rehabilitation tax credits and grants do come with standards, so if you're using them, the roof has to meet them.

What does like-kind slate mean?

Slate that matches the original in size, shape, color, texture, exposure and coursing, the characteristics the National Park Service's Preservation Brief 29 says to document and match. Color also means how the slate weathers: some slates hold their color and others weather to a different shade over time.

Can you reuse my old slate?

Often, at least some of it. When the roof is failing because of rusted nails or worn-out flashing rather than worn-out stone, sound slate can be salvaged. Every piece is sounded and checked for cracks and weathering. Salvaged slate is ideal for patching the roof sections that stay, and for future repairs.

How long does a historic slate reroof take?

It depends on the size of the roof, the slate lead time and the weather. Construction in both towns is limited to 7 a.m. to 6 p.m., Monday through Saturday, so we plan the work in sections that can be closed up with underlayment each day. We give you a written schedule before we start.

Get a free roof inspection

We get on the roof, photograph what we find, and tell you plainly whether you need a repair or a replacement.

Get a free estimate

Tell us how to reach you. Blake or the team will call you back.

Or call (817) 733-9228 snowexteriors@gmail.com