Offices in Bridgeport · Decatur · Rhome · Class 3+ impact-rated shingles on every roof Call (817) 733-9228
Snow Roofing & Exteriors logo

Free Roof Replacement Estimate

📞 Call (817) 733-9228
Blog

Enviroshake vs. DaVinci Shake for Colleyville and Southlake Estates: Look, Color, Weight, Hail, Fire, Wind and Warranty Side by Side

By Blake Snow, owner ·

Drone view of a gray composite Enviroshake roof with a stone chimney and dark standing seam metal sections on a stone ranch home
Enviroshake with standing seam metal sections

On the big homes in Colleyville and Southlake, cedar shake is still one of the looks people want most: on a Hill Country stone house, a French country home, a modern farmhouse with a stone base. Real cedar in North Texas means heat, sun, hail and upkeep. So most of the shake roofs I’m asked to price on these streets now are composite, and the two names that come up over and over are Enviroshake and DaVinci.

I’m Blake Snow. I’ve been roofing for 30 years, and our crews have completed over $80 million in roofing projects. I’m a certified Enviroshake installer and an Enviroshake representative, so you should know where I stand. I also have experience installing and repairing DaVinci, and both are good products. This post puts them side by side using each maker’s own published numbers, so you can pick the one that fits your house instead of the one a salesman happens to carry.

If you’re still deciding between composite and real wood, start with Enviroshake vs. real cedar shake after North Texas hail.

The short version

  • Enviroshake is a color-through composite made from 95% post-industrial recycled material. It’s designed to weather in its first year to a matte, aged-cedar look and then hold it. Pick it if you want the roof to look like cedar that has been on the house a while.
  • DaVinci shake is molded from virgin resins with UV and thermal stabilizers, in a wide range of fixed color blends. DaVinci says the color you pick is the color you’ll have decades from now. Pick it if you want a set color or a blend you can match to a specific stone or brick.
  • Both list Class 4 hail and Class A fire ratings. Wind, weight, pitch and warranty differ in the details, and the details are below.
  • The install decides more than the brand. Gaps, nails, underlayment, starter courses and flashings are where a premium composite roof is made or ruined.
  • Standing seam on the low sections (porches, bays, patio covers) is the classic pairing with either one.

What each one is made of

Enviroshake says its exact formula is a trade secret, but describes it as a composite of 95% post-industrial recycled materials, including plastics, natural fibers and elastomers, with additives for UV protection. The pieces are molded from 3D images of real shakes, and the color runs all the way through, with no paint or coating on the surface. Each Enviroshake piece is 12 inches wide and 20 inches long, and the shake comes in six profiles. The maker says the tiles are 100% recyclable.

DaVinci (now part of Westlake Royal Building Products) describes its shake as virgin resins with UV and thermal stabilizers and a fire retardant. It offers three shake lines: Single-Width Shake (9-inch pieces, a tidy, uniform look), Multi-Width Shake (4-, 6-, 7-, 8- and 9-inch widths for a rough, hand-split look) and Select Shake. DaVinci also has Bellaforte Shake, a lighter, thicker-butt piece. The field pieces in Single-Width and Multi-Width are 22 inches long, 5/8 inch at the butt and 1/4 inch at the tip.

Side by side

EnviroshakeDaVinci shake
MaterialComposite, 95% post-industrial recycled content, color-throughMolded virgin resins with UV and thermal stabilizers
How the color agesDesigned to weather in the first year to a matte aged-cedar look, then hold itDaVinci says no fading: the color you pick is the color you keep
Common colorsAged Cedar, Silvered Cedar, Multi-Tone; custom colors availableMany blends, from new cedar tones to weathered grays; cool-roof colors on some
Piece size12 in. wide x 20 in. long22 in. long; 9 in. (Single-Width) or 4 to 9 in. mixed (Multi-Width)
WeightAbout 260 lb per squareAbout 297 to 333 lb per square (Single-Width / Multi-Width); about 194 lb (Bellaforte)
Minimum pitch2:12 recommended minimum, with a separate low-slope guide under 3:123:12 or 4:12 and up depending on the product and sheet date; check the current tech sheet
HailUL 2218 Class 4UL 2218 Class 4
FireClass A (ASTM E108) without a special underlayment; Class C product also soldClass A on all DaVinci roofing products
WindUp to 180 mph; exceeds Miami-Dade HVHZ requirementsCertified to 110 mph (ASTM D3161); up to 180 mph in the hurricane-zone test
Other listingsFORTIFIED Roof approved product, WUI compliantTexas Department of Insurance, Miami-Dade, ICC-ES evaluation report
Warranty25-year Standard or 50-year Gold (Gold needs Enviroshield underlayment), fully transferableLifetime Limited Material Warranty on homes; 50 years commercial
Installer ruleFactory Trained Installer required, and the roof must be registeredInstall to DaVinci’s instructions; read the warranty for registration steps

Sources: Enviroshake FAQs, Enviroshake warranty and registration, Enviroshake installer FAQs, DaVinci shake overview and DaVinci’s shake technical sheet. Makers update these documents, so we pull the current versions for every quote.

The real decision: how do you want it to look in year five?

This is the question that settles it for most of my Colleyville and Southlake clients.

Enviroshake looks like cedar that has lived on the house. It goes through a weathering period in its first year, then settles into a matte, aged look with natural variation from piece to piece. On a stone house with mature oaks, that softer, weathered look is usually what the architect drew. The trade-off: you’re choosing the weathered look on purpose. If you want the roof to stay exactly the shade of the sample, this isn’t the product.

DaVinci looks like the day you picked it. It’s sold on color stability, and the range of blends is wide. That’s a real advantage when you’re matching a specific stone, brick or trim color, or when an HOA approved one exact color and wants to see that color forever. The trade-off: with fixed colors and molded pieces, the installer has to mix widths and blend bundles carefully so the roof doesn’t look uniform from the street.

A simple way to think about it:

If you want…Lean toward
The look of cedar that has aged naturallyEnviroshake
A fixed color that stays the sameDaVinci
The widest choice of color blendsDaVinci
A tidy, uniform shake lineDaVinci Single-Width
A rough, hand-split, mixed-width lookDaVinci Multi-Width or Enviroshake
The strongest recycled-content storyEnviroshake
Low-slope sections near 2:12 in the same productEnviroshake (with its low-slope guide), or switch those sections to standing seam
The lightest composite shake on the framingDaVinci Bellaforte or Enviroshake

Hail, fire and wind in North Texas

Both products list UL 2218 Class 4, the top impact rating in that test. Enviroshake says its products aren’t damaged by hail, falling debris or foot traffic. I’ll tell you what I tell everyone: no roof is hail-proof. What a Class 4 rating buys you is a roof that’s far more likely to come through a normal North Texas storm without broken or split pieces. Ask your own insurance agent, in writing, whether a Class 4 roof earns a discount on your policy; see our Texas impact-resistant roof discount guide.

On fire, both list Class A. Enviroshake says its Class A rating was reached without a special underlayment, but it also sells a Class C product, so make sure your proposal says which one you’re buying. DaVinci says all of its roofing products are Class A.

On wind, Enviroshake lists up to 180 mph. DaVinci’s shake sheet lists certification to 110 mph under ASTM D3161 and up to 180 mph in the hurricane-zone test. Both are more than most Colleyville and Southlake homes need, but open lots and tall two-story gables catch more wind than you’d think, so the nailing pattern and edge details matter.

Hail near Colleyville and Southlake

NOAA’s Storm Events Database lists these reports of 1.75-inch (golf-ball size) or larger hail within about 10 miles of each city, from 2016 through the latest data NOAA has published (mid-2026):

CityReports of 1.75 in. or larger hail within 10 mi
Colleyville39
Southlake51

A few dates from those records:

  • June 11, 2023: 4.25-inch hail near Bartonville and 4-inch hail at Grapevine Reservoir.
  • May 27, 2024: 1.5-inch hail reported in Colleyville and 2.75-inch hail in Bedford, about 2.5 miles from the center of Colleyville.
  • April 28, 2021: 3-inch and 3.25-inch hail reported in Keller.

That’s hail country. It’s the reason a published Class 4 rating, a properly fastened install and good metal flashings matter more here than in most of the country. Texas generally gives you 1 year from the date of loss to file a claim; check your policy.

Install details that make or break a composite shake roof

This is where a premium roof gets wasted by a cheap install. Whichever product you choose, these items should be on the proposal:

  • Gapping. Composite pieces move a little with heat. Enviroshake requires at least a 3/8-inch gap between every piece, and DaVinci’s numbers are based on a 3/8-inch gap too. Tight pieces buckle in a Texas August.
  • Nails. Enviroshake calls for four nails per piece, with 1 1/2-inch stainless steel ring-shank nails recommended. DaVinci lists its own nail counts and nail types per square on its tech sheet. Wrong nails or missed nail zones show up in the first big wind.
  • Exposure. Enviroshake is designed for a 9-inch exposure. DaVinci shake goes on at 9 or 10 inches depending on whether it’s staggered. Exposure changes the look and the material count, so two quotes with different exposures aren’t the same roof.
  • Underlayment. Enviroshake’s 50-year Gold warranty requires Enviroshield synthetic underlayment. DaVinci suggests a felt interlay on any pitch and requires it on lower pitches, per its sheet. Ask what’s going under your roof by name.
  • Starter, hip and ridge. Both makers sell their own starter and hip and ridge pieces; Enviroshake forms its caps to the roof’s slope. Field pieces cut and bent over a ridge are a shortcut you’ll see from the yard.
  • Flashings. On stone chimneys, dormers and wall tie-ins, the flashing is the roof. We like heavy metal flashings and, on the right house, copper. See copper flashing, valleys and gutters on slate and tile.
  • The installer requirement. Enviroshake’s warranty is only valid when a Factory Trained Installer does the work and the roof is registered. Ask any roofer for proof before you sign.

Pair it with standing seam on the low sections

Most estate homes have spots where a shake roof doesn’t belong: a low porch, a bay, a patio cover, a connector to a pool house. Standing seam metal is the classic answer, and it looks right next to both Enviroshake and DaVinci. The photo at the top of this post is an Enviroshake roof we installed with standing seam sections on the lower roofs.

We run our own roll formers for standing seam, in 24 or 26 gauge, and metal lead time is typically 1 to 2 weeks. See standing seam in Colleyville, standing seam in Southlake, our Enviroshake and standing seam ranch estate project and patio covers that match the main roof.

Cost: what moves the price

I won’t put a number on a composite shake roof without seeing the house. Both makers are premium products, and Enviroshake says its pricing is comparable to other synthetics. On these homes, what really moves the price is:

  • Roof size, pitch and how cut up it is (hips, valleys, dormers, turrets)
  • Tear-off of the old roof and any decking that has to be replaced
  • Which product line, and Standard vs. Gold-level warranty requirements
  • Underlayment, starter, hip and ridge pieces and nails specified by the maker
  • Flashing metal (painted steel vs. copper) at chimneys, walls and valleys
  • Standing seam sections, gutters and any soffit and fascia work done at the same time

When you compare quotes, compare the same product line, exposure, underlayment, flashing metal and warranty. A cheaper number almost always means one of those changed.

HOA approval in Colleyville and Southlake

Many Colleyville and Southlake neighborhoods have architectural review. Most committees will want the product name, profile, color and a sample or product sheet. Get the approval in writing before anything is ordered, and if you’re choosing Enviroshake, show the committee the weathered look, not just the new sample. With DaVinci, submit the exact blend name. We’ll provide product sheets and samples for your submittal. See getting HOA approval for an Enviroshake roof for how we put a submittal together.

Permits in Colleyville and Southlake

  • Colleyville: the city requires a permit on every re-roof, and contractors have to be registered with the city.
  • Southlake: the city’s When is a permit required? list includes replacing roofing materials, and contractors have to be registered with the city.

HOA approval and the city permit are separate. One doesn’t replace the other. We pull the permits.

12 questions to ask before you sign

  1. Which exact product line is on the proposal (Enviroshake, or DaVinci Single-Width, Multi-Width, Select or Bellaforte)?
  2. What color, and have I seen it weathered (Enviroshake) or in a full-size sample (DaVinci)?
  3. What exposure, and is it straight or staggered?
  4. What underlayment, by name, and does it qualify for the warranty level I’m paying for?
  5. What nails, how many per piece, and stainless or galvanized?
  6. Will you gap every piece to the maker’s spec?
  7. Are the starter, hip and ridge pieces the maker’s own?
  8. What flashing metal at the chimneys, walls and valleys?
  9. For Enviroshake: is a Factory Trained Installer on site every day, and who registers the roof?
  10. Which fire-rated assembly is this, Class A or Class C?
  11. What goes on the low-slope sections: the same product or standing seam?
  12. Who pulls the permit, who handles the HOA submittal, and what’s the workmanship warranty in writing?

Nearby towns

We install and repair composite shake across northeast Tarrant and south Denton County, including Westlake, Trophy Club, Keller and Grapevine. See Enviroshake in Colleyville, Enviroshake in Southlake, Enviroshake in Westlake, synthetic cedar shake and all our synthetic roofing options.

Get both options priced on your house

We’re certified with GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, Atlas, Johns Manville, Carlisle, Tropical Roofing Products, Mule-Hide and Enviroshake, and many other roof manufacturers. Snow Roofing & Exteriors is fully insured, has offices in Bridgeport, Decatur and Rhome, is A+ rated on the BBB, and has 5.0 stars on Google at all three offices: Bridgeport, Decatur and Rhome. References are available on request. Our workmanship warranty runs from 10 years up to lifetime, depending on the job.

Call (817) 733-9228 or request an estimate. Bring us your house, your HOA’s rules and the look you want in year five, and we’ll price Enviroshake and DaVinci side by side, line for line, so you can choose with the facts in front of you.

Frequently asked questions

What is the main difference between Enviroshake and DaVinci shake?

How the color behaves. Enviroshake is a color-through composite made from 95% post-industrial recycled material, and the maker says it's designed to weather in its first year to a matte, weathered cedar look and then hold that look. DaVinci shake is molded from virgin resins with UV and thermal stabilizers, and DaVinci says the color you pick today is the color you'll have decades from now. If you want the roof to look like cedar that has aged, lean Enviroshake. If you want a fixed color and the widest choice of blends, lean DaVinci.

Which one is better in hail?

Both makers list a UL 2218 Class 4 impact rating, the top rating in that test. No roof is hail-proof. In practice the install details (deck, underlayment, fasteners, flashings) and the metal on the roof decide how a composite roof looks after a big storm as much as the product does.

Are Enviroshake and DaVinci fire rated?

Both list a Class A fire rating. Enviroshake says its Class A rating (ASTM E108) was achieved without a special underlayment, and that a Class C product is also available, so confirm which one your quote is for. DaVinci says all of its roofing products carry a Class A rating. Ask that the fire-rated assembly be named on the proposal.

Which one weighs more?

By each maker's published numbers, Enviroshake is about 260 pounds per square. DaVinci's shake tech sheet lists about 297 to 333 pounds per square for Single-Width and Multi-Width Shake depending on exposure, and about 194 pounds for Bellaforte Shake. All are far lighter than slate or tile, and either one usually goes on a house that carried cedar or asphalt without new framing, but we still check the structure.

What warranty comes with each?

Enviroshake lists a 25-year Standard warranty and a 50-year Gold warranty, both fully transferable, with Gold requiring Enviroshield synthetic underlayment, and only roofs installed by a Factory Trained Installer and registered qualify. DaVinci lists a Lifetime Limited Material Warranty on homes and 50 years on commercial projects. Read each maker's current warranty document before you sign, and get the workmanship warranty in writing too.

Do you install both?

Yes. Blake Snow is a certified Enviroshake installer and Enviroshake representative, so you should know that going in. He also has experience installing and repairing DaVinci, and we'll tell you honestly when DaVinci is the better fit for your house.

Do I need a permit and HOA approval for a composite shake roof in Colleyville or Southlake?

Yes on the permit. The City of Colleyville requires a permit on every re-roof, and Southlake's permit list includes replacing roofing materials; both require the contractor to be registered with the city. HOA approval is separate. Get the product, profile and color approved in writing first, then pull the permit. We pull the permits and help with the submittal.

How long do I have to file a hail claim in Texas?

Generally 1 year from the date of loss in Texas, but check your policy. Get the roof inspected first and file only if the inspection finds storm damage.

Get a free roof inspection

We get on the roof, photograph what we find, and tell you plainly whether you need a repair or a replacement.

Free Roof Replacement Estimate

📞 Call (817) 733-9228

Certified with GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, Atlas, Johns Manville, Carlisle, Tropical Roofing Products, Mule-Hide and Enviroshake

Atlas Roofing certified contractor
📞 (817) 733-9228