Snow Roofing & Exteriors logo Call (817) 733-9228
Blog

Karnak Roof Coatings on Metal and Smooth Low-Slope Roofs in Decatur: 670HS Karna-Sil Ultra vs. 501 Elasto-Brite

By Blake Snow, owner ·

Illustration of a roofer rolling white silicone coating over a galvanized metal shop roof, half coated and half bare
Illustration

Drive around Decatur and the rest of Wise County and you’ll see a lot of metal: shops, ag barns, equipment sheds, small warehouses and church fellowship halls, plus plenty of commercial buildings with a smooth low-slope roof behind the parapet. Many of those roofs aren’t worn out. The fasteners are backing out, the seams weep, the paint has chalked off, and the building gets hot. That’s where a coating earns its keep.

I’m Blake Snow. I’ve been roofing for 30 years, and Karnak is one of the coating brands we install. I already wrote about Karnak, APOC and Henry coatings on old built-up roofs. This post is about the jobs I see more often around Decatur: metal roofs and smooth low-slope roofs, and Karnak’s two main finish coats for them, 670HS Karna-Sil Ultra (silicone) and 501 Elasto-Brite (acrylic).

The short answer

  • Bare galvanized metal, want one coat and done? Karnak 670HS Karna-Sil Ultra. Karnak says no primer is needed on bare galvanized.
  • Metal that drains well and a budget that favors acrylic? Karnak 501 Elasto-Brite, usually over a base coat like 404 Corrosion Proof Base where there’s rust.
  • Smooth TPO, PVC, EPDM, mod bit or smooth BUR? Usually 670HS over the base coat or primer Karnak lists for that surface. Aged TPO and PVC need to be at least 4 years old for 501.
  • Either way, the prep decides the result: fasteners, seams, rust and wet insulation get fixed first.

Karnak 670HS vs. 501 Elasto-Brite: Karnak’s published numbers

670HS Karna-Sil Ultra501 Elasto-Brite
ChemistrySingle-component, high-solids, moisture-cure siliconeCo-polymer elastomeric, 100% acrylic emulsion
StandardASTM D6694ASTM D6083 Type I
Solids by volume91% (nominal)53% (nominal)
Solids by weight94% (nominal)63% (nominal)
Elongation212% at 73°F237%
Tensile strength227 psi at 73°F259 psi
Solar reflectance (white)0.87 initial / 0.70 3-yr aged0.86 initial / 0.77 3-yr aged
SRI (white)110 initial / 86 3-yr aged109 initial / 96 3-yr aged
Application temperature50°F to 120°F40°F to 120°F
Cure2 hrs at 95°F/90% RH; 8 hrs at 50°F/20% RH24 to 48 hrs at 77°F/50% RH
VOCUnder 50 g/L42 g/L max
NotesMiami-Dade approved; NSF listed for rainwater catchment; no rain within 24 hrs of application; Karnak says all surfaces must have positive drainageFor metal, aged BUR (90 days), SBS/APP mod bit (30 days), aged TPO/PVC (4+ years)

Sources: Karnak’s 670HS Karna-Sil Ultra page, 501 Elasto-Brite page and 501 Elasto-Brite data sheet. These are typical published values.

Two things jump out. First, solids: a 91%-solids silicone keeps almost all of its wet thickness, while a 53%-solids acrylic loses close to half as the water leaves. That’s why acrylic goes on in more coats. Second, aged reflectance: in Karnak’s own numbers, the acrylic held more of its reflectance after three years than the silicone did. Silicone tends to pick up more dirt. On a Wise County shop next to a gravel drive, that’s worth knowing.

Primers and base coats by roof type (from Karnak’s 670HS listing)

Existing roofWhat Karnak lists before 670HS
Bare galvanized metal, concrete, new SPF foam, old siliconeNo primer required
Painted metal180 Karna-Sil Ultra Epoxy Primer
TPO, PVC, Hypalon, EPDM406 Tru-Grip, 405 Bond-N-Shield, or 180 Epoxy Primer
Smooth BUR, smooth or granulated mod bit406 Tru-Grip, 405 Bond-N-Shield, or 180 Epoxy Primer (new BUR aged 90 to 180 days; mod bit 30 days)

We still run an adhesion test on the actual roof. A primer chart tells you what should stick. A pull test tells you what does.

What a proper Karnak metal-roof job looks like

Karnak’s published galvanized metal system specification lays out the steps, and they match how we do it:

  1. Clean: 799 Wash-N-Prep, then rinse. Coatings don’t stick to chalk, dirt or oil.
  2. Fasteners and seams: 502MS Karna-Flex sealant on seams, fasteners, curbs and penetrations, reinforced with 5540 Resat-Mat polyester fabric where needed. Backed-out or stripped screws get replaced or upsized first.
  3. Rust: sound, prepared rusted areas get spot-treated with 404 Corrosion Proof Base Coat. Panels rusted through get replaced, not painted.
  4. Finish coat: 670HS Karna-Sil Ultra in a single coat, listed at 3.0 gallons per 100 sq. ft. on galvanized metal, with no rain expected for 24 hours. For an acrylic system, 501 Elasto-Brite goes over the base coat in multiple coats.

Karnak notes its coverage rates are for estimating, and actual amounts vary with the surface. For warranty jobs, Karnak’s specs require the project to be submitted and approved before work starts, and the warranty term depends on the system and application rate. We’ll show you the Karnak warranty terms in writing before we start.

When a coating is the wrong answer

I’ll tell you straight when coating doesn’t make sense:

  • Wet insulation under a low-slope roof. Coating over it traps the water. We check with a moisture survey first.
  • Rusted-through panels or failed purlin connections. That’s a re-panel job. We run our own roll formers for 24- and 26-gauge R-panel and standing seam, and offer PBR and corrugated panels, with a typical lead time of 1 to 2 weeks. See our Decatur metal roofing page.
  • A roof that ponds for days. Karnak says 670HS surfaces must have positive drainage. Fix the drainage first.

More on that decision on our roof coating vs. replacement page.

Other coatings we can bid side by side

Karnak isn’t the only option. We’re certified with Mule-Hide and Tropical Roofing Products, both of which make coatings, we’re an American WeatherStar Approved Contractor, and we offer EpoxyFlex, our own private-label roof coating. See my Mule-Hide silicone vs. acrylic post and Sherwin-Williams Uniflex post for comparisons.

Questions to ask before you sign a coating bid

  1. Which Karnak products exactly, and is it silicone or acrylic?
  2. How many gallons per 100 sq. ft. of finish coat?
  3. Which primer or base coat, and was an adhesion test done?
  4. How will fasteners be handled: sealed, replaced or upsized?
  5. How are seams, curbs and penetrations reinforced?
  6. Is a moisture survey included for low-slope areas?
  7. Which Karnak warranty, how many years, and who submits it before work starts?
  8. What’s the weather plan if rain is forecast inside 24 hours?

After a storm

Get a hail-damaged metal or low-slope roof inspected and documented before anyone coats it. A coating is not a hail repair. Our FAA-certified drone pilot can fly the roof, see our drone roof inspection page. Check storm history in the NOAA NCEI Storm Events Database. In Texas it’s generally 1 year from the date of loss to file a claim, but check your policy.

Talk to us about a coating in Decatur

We coat and restore metal and low-slope roofs across Decatur, Bridgeport, Alvord, Paradise, Boyd and Rhome. We’re certified with GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, Atlas, Johns Manville, Carlisle, Tropical Roofing Products, Mule-Hide and Enviroshake, and many other roof manufacturers. Commercial jobs can carry 10- and 20-year NDL warranties. We’re fully insured, BBB A+ rated, and have 5.0 stars on Google at all three offices: Bridgeport, Decatur and Rhome.

See our Karnak coatings page, metal roof coating page and Decatur commercial roofing page, use the estimate form below, or call (817) 733-9228.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Which Karnak coating is better for a metal roof, silicone or acrylic?

Both are used on metal. Karnak's 670HS Karna-Sil Ultra is a single-coat, high-solids (91% by volume) moisture-cure silicone that goes straight onto bare galvanized metal with no primer. Karnak's 501 Elasto-Brite is a 100% acrylic (53% solids by volume) that's usually applied in two coats. On a metal shop that sheds water well, either can work; we pick based on the condition of the panels, the budget and how fast the job has to be done.

Does Karnak silicone need a primer on metal?

On bare galvanized metal, Karnak's 670HS product page says no primer is required. On painted metal, Karnak calls for its 180 Karna-Sil Ultra Epoxy Primer. Rusted areas get spot-treated first; Karnak's metal system specifications use 404 Corrosion Proof Base Coat for that.

Can Karnak coatings go over an old gravel built-up roof?

That's a different job. This post covers metal and smooth low-slope roofs. Karnak's 670HS lists smooth BUR and smooth or granulated modified bitumen as surfaces it can go over with the right base coat or primer. For old gravel-surfaced built-up roofs, see my separate post on APOC, Henry and Karnak coatings for old built-up roofs.

How much Karnak coating does a metal roof need?

Karnak's published galvanized metal system specification lists 670HS Karna-Sil Ultra at 3.0 gallons per 100 sq. ft. in a single coat. Karnak notes coverage rates are for estimating only and actual amounts depend on the roof surface. Always check that your bid states gallons per 100 sq. ft.

Can a coating fix hail damage on a metal building?

No. A coating can seal fasteners and seams and add reflectivity, but it isn't a hail repair, and coating over undocumented damage can complicate a claim. Get the roof inspected first. In Texas it's generally 1 year from the date of loss to file, but check your policy.

Get a free roof inspection

We get on the roof, photograph what we find, and tell you plainly whether you need a repair or a replacement.

Get a free estimate

Tell us how to reach you. Blake or the team will call you back.

Or call (817) 733-9228