Offices in Bridgeport · Decatur · Rhome · Class 3+ impact-rated shingles on every roof Call (817) 733-9228
Snow Roofing & Exteriors logo

Free Roof Replacement Estimate

📞 Call (817) 733-9228
Blog

Tile Roof Hail Check After a Storm in Westlake and Trophy Club: Walk Paths, Cracked vs. Slipped Tile, Underlayment

By Blake Snow, owner ·

Illustration of an aerial drone view over a Mediterranean-style estate home with a terracotta clay tile roof, hips, valleys and chimneys, surrounded by trees and a stone courtyard
Illustration

Tile roofs in Westlake and Trophy Club are some of the best roofs in North Texas. Clay and concrete tile shrug off sun and heat for decades, and most hail that comes through bounces off. But big hail does break tile, and the way most people check a roof after a storm (climb up and walk it) is the fastest way to break more of it.

I’m Blake Snow. I’ve been roofing for 30 years, our crews have completed over $80 million in roofing projects, and tile is the work I like best. This post is about one thing: what to do, and what a real inspection looks like, after hail hits a clay or concrete tile roof. If your tile roof is leaking and the tile looks fine, read my post on underlayment and lift-and-relay too.

The short version

  • Stay off the roof. Check from the ground, the driveway, the gutters and the attic. Tile breaks underfoot and is slick when wet.
  • Hail size matters. Small hail rarely hurts sound, well-installed tile. Golf-ball size and up is when broken tile becomes likely, and older or weathered tile can break sooner.
  • Not every broken tile is hail. Hail breaks, old breaks, foot-traffic breaks and slipped tile look different, and an honest inspection separates them.
  • The underlayment is the roof. The tile sheds most of the water; the layer under it keeps the house dry. A cracked tile over tired underlayment is how a hail hit turns into a leak.
  • Inspect without walking where you don’t need to. Drone first, then a planned walk path on supported tile only.
  • Repairs need matching tile. Identify the tile first. Some products, like Lifetile, are discontinued, so matching means salvage or harvesting.
  • Know your deadlines. Texas claims are generally 1 year from the date of loss; check your policy.

Right after the storm: what you can check from the ground

You can learn a lot without a ladder. Walk the property the day after the storm, in daylight, and take dated photos as you go.

Where to lookWhat you’re looking forWhat it tells you
Driveway, beds, patio and pool deckPieces of red, brown or gray tile, ridge mortar or cap piecesSomething broke up top. Save a few pieces for the inspection.
Gutters and downspout outletsTile chips, mortar, dents in the gutter faceBroken tile or ridge pieces, and how hard the hail hit
Soft metals: AC fins, vent caps, mailbox, gutter downspoutsRound dents or spatter marksA rough read on hail size and direction on your lot
Windowsills, siding, fence, patio furnitureDents, chips, split vinyl, spatterWhich side of the house took the storm. See siding after hail.
Roof from the yard (binoculars or a phone zoom)Gaps in the rows, a tile sitting lower than its neighbors, dark spots, missing hip or ridge piecesPossible broken or slipped tile
Attic, with a flashlightWet decking, drips at nails, stained underlayment, daylightWater already getting through
Ceilings and upstairs wallsNew stains, bubbling paint, drips at light fixturesAn active leak. Call us before the next rain.

What not to do: don’t climb onto the tile, don’t let someone you don’t know walk it, and don’t pressure-wash or “spot fix” anything with caulk or foam. Those make the real repair harder and can muddy an insurance claim.

Why a tile roof needs a different kind of inspection

A shingle roof can be walked almost anywhere. A tile roof can’t. Each tile is supported where it overlaps the tile below it and on the battens or deck; the rest of it spans air. Step in the wrong spot and a sound tile cracks.

The Tile Roofing Industry Alliance’s walkability guidance and maintenance guide say to:

  • Step on the bottom 3 inches of the installed tile, where it’s supported by the tile lapped beneath it.
  • Keep your feet parallel to the ridge, spread your weight and walk softly.
  • On high-profile “S” tile, put heel and toe on the high points of adjacent tiles.
  • Stay off hips and valleys, where the cut tiles are harder to replace.
  • Let only trained, insured professionals with fall protection walk a tile roof.

Here’s how we inspect a tile roof after hail:

  1. Drone first. Our drone pilot is FAA Part 107 certified. A drone inspection photographs every slope, hip, valley and ridge from above without anyone stepping on tile, and it shows us which areas actually need a closer look.
  2. Thermal where there’s a leak. If there’s a stain or a wet ceiling, infrared leak detection helps trace where water is getting in, since it often isn’t right above the stain.
  3. A planned walk path. Where we need hands-on, we plan the path before anyone goes up: supported tile only, off the hips and valleys, never on wet tile or morning dew, with roof ladders and pads where needed.
  4. Lift and look. On the damaged slopes we lift a few tiles to see the underlayment, the fasteners and the battens. That’s the part a drone can’t do.
  5. Piece-by-piece report. You get a free digital photo report that separates fresh hail breaks, old breaks, foot-traffic breaks, slipped tile and installation issues, slope by slope.

How big was the hail? It matters on tile

Tile is tough. One forensic engineering firm, Vertex, writes that field observations and lab testing show hailstones under 2 inches in diameter generally won’t damage competent, properly installed concrete or clay tile. “Competent” is the key word: tile that’s already cracked, weathered, poorly supported or walked on can break at smaller sizes, and large hail can break any tile.

So the first question after a storm is how big the hail was near your street, and which direction it came from. That’s what the soft-metal dents on your lot and the NOAA records help answer.

Cracked, broken, slipped or old? How to tell them apart

This is the heart of a tile hail inspection. The same roof can have all of these, and they lead to different answers.

What we findWhat it looks likeUsual causeWhat we do
Fresh hail fractureClean, unweathered edges; crescent-shaped break at an edge, a star pattern from the impact point, or a shattered tile; spatter or impact marks nearby; concentrated on storm-facing slopesHailPhotograph, count by slope, replace with matching tile, check the underlayment under it
Old breakDirty, stained or darkened edges; growth or debris in the crack; no pattern by slopeAn earlier storm, age, past foot trafficNote it separately; repair it with the rest so the roof is sound
Foot-traffic breakCracks across the unsupported part of the tile, along batten lines, or on paths to vents, satellite dishes, solar panels, HVAC units and holiday-light routesPeople walking the roofReplace; tell you where it came from
Slipped tileA tile sitting lower than its row, a gap above it, underlayment or batten visibleFailed nail or clip, broken nose or lug, a cracked tile that let goRe-secure to the manufacturer’s method; check and patch underlayment while it’s open
Corner crack or chip, often lower cornerSmall cracks at the same corner on many tiles, no impact markTiles set too tight to expand, or handling during installationNote as an installation issue; replace where needed
Surface wear on concrete tileFaded or worn coating, rough or pitted surface, no fractureAge and weatherUsually cosmetic; we note it, since it affects matching
Broken hip, ridge or rake piecesCracked or missing cap, loose or failed mortar, bare ridge nailerHail, wind or ageRe-set caps to current methods; replace damaged pieces

Clay vs. concrete. Clay tile tends to fracture cleanly or shatter when hail breaks it, so damage is easier to spot. Concrete tile is thicker and heavier, and older concrete tile can show worn surface coating that isn’t hail damage at all. See clay tile, concrete tile and my post on clay vs. concrete tile.

Wind vs. hail. Wind rarely breaks tile by itself. What wind does is lift loose hip and ridge pieces and push already-slipped tile further, and storm debris such as tree limbs can break tile. We note which is which.

The underlayment: the part that actually keeps you dry

On most tile roofs, the tile is the rain shield. The felt or synthetic underlayment under it is the waterproofing. That’s why a tile roof can look perfect from the street and still leak.

After hail, we check the underlayment wherever the tile is broken or slipped, and on a few test spots per slope:

  • Is it intact? Look for tears, holes from shattered tile, or punctures from foot traffic.
  • Is it still flexible? Old felt that has dried out cracks when you lift it. If it crumbles, the roof is living on borrowed time whether hail hit it or not.
  • Is the deck dry? Staining, soft decking or rusted fasteners mean water has been getting through.
  • Battens and fasteners. Rotted battens or rusted nails explain slipped tile and tell us whether spot repairs will hold.
  • Flashings. Valleys, headwalls, chimneys, skylights and pipe penetrations are where most tile leaks start. Hail dents vent caps and soft metal flashings too.

If the underlayment is sound, broken tile can usually be replaced piece by piece. If it’s worn out, replacing a few tiles won’t stop the leaks, and a tile lift-and-relay is usually the right fix: we take the tile up, replace the underlayment and flashings, and re-lay the same tile, replacing broken pieces with matching ones. Copper valleys and flashings are a common upgrade while the roof is open; see copper flashing, valleys and gutters on tile.

Whether worn-out underlayment is covered by a hail claim is up to your policy and adjuster. Storm damage and age-related wear are different things, and our report keeps them separate.

Repair, lift-and-relay or replace?

What the inspection findsWhat I’d usually recommend
A handful of broken tiles, underlayment sound, matching tile availableReplace the broken tiles and re-secure any slipped pieces
Broken tiles scattered across one or two storm-facing slopes, underlayment soundSlope-by-slope repair with matching tile
Broken tile anywhere, underlayment dried out, torn or leakingLift-and-relay: new underlayment and flashings, same tile back on, broken pieces replaced
Widespread fractures on most slopes, or tile that breaks when handledReplacement, with new tile or another high-end roof
Your tile is no longer made and no close match existsHarvest tiles from hidden slopes for the street side, then use a close-matching tile on the back

The Tile Roofing Industry Alliance’s post-storm repair guide describes this “harvest and repair” method: tiles come off inconspicuous, non-street-facing slopes to fix the visible ones, and the harvested areas get a tile of similar shape and, where possible, color.

Matching tile on Westlake and Trophy Club homes

Every tile repair starts with identifying the tile: maker, profile (flat, S, barrel, interlocking), size and color blend. Many Westlake and Trophy Club homes have concrete tile from the 1990s and 2000s, and colors and profiles have changed since.

  • Still in production? We check the current lines from makers like Eagle, Westlake Royal and Ludowici.
  • Discontinued? Lifetile concrete tile is discontinued, so matching it means salvage stock or harvesting; see Lifetile concrete tile on Mediterranean homes.
  • Color blends weather. Even a current tile in the “same” color can read differently next to 20-year-old tile, so we lay samples against the roof in daylight before anyone commits.
  • Keep spares. If you have leftover tile in the garage or attic, don’t throw it out. Those are the best match you’ll ever find.

Hail near Westlake and Trophy Club

NOAA’s Storm Events Database lists these reports of 1.75-inch (golf-ball size) or larger hail within about 10 miles of each town, from 2016 through the latest 2026 data NOAA has published (events through May 2026):

TownReports of 1.75 in. or larger hail within 10 mi
Westlake53
Trophy Club53

The two towns sit next to each other, so they share most of the same storms. A few dates from those records:

  • June 11, 2023: 4.25-inch hail near Bartonville, about 4.5 miles from Trophy Club and under 6 miles from Westlake; 3-inch hail at Grapevine Reservoir, about 3.5 miles from Trophy Club; and 2.5-inch hail in Roanoke, about 2 miles from Westlake.
  • May 27, 2024: 2-inch hail near the Roanoke airport, under 3 miles from both towns.
  • March 14, 2024: 3-inch hail near the Roanoke airport, about 4 miles from Westlake.
  • April 28, 2021: 1.75-inch hail in Roanoke, under a mile from both towns, and 3.25-inch hail in Keller, about 4.5 miles from Westlake.
  • April 28, 2026: 1.25-inch hail reported in Southlake and Keller, about 4 to 5 miles away.

Those are the sizes that can break tile. A gap in the record doesn’t mean no hail fell; it means no one reported it. If a storm came through and you’re not sure, have the roof looked at.

Insurance: what a good tile hail report includes

If you file a claim, the adjuster needs to see storm damage, not just “some broken tile.” A good report has:

  1. The storm date and the hail size reported nearby.
  2. Overview photos of every slope, plus close-ups of each damaged tile.
  3. Damage counted by slope, with fresh hail breaks separated from old, foot-traffic and installation breaks.
  4. Soft-metal damage (vents, flashings, gutters) that confirms hail size and direction.
  5. Underlayment, batten and flashing condition where tile was lifted.
  6. The tile identified, and whether matching tile is available.

We meet your adjuster on the roof when you want us there. In Texas you generally have 1 year from the date of loss to file a claim; check your policy. Texas law requires you to pay your deductible, and a contractor may not waive, absorb or rebate it. We never will. See storm damage for the rest of the process.

Permits in Westlake and Trophy Club

Town of Westlake. The town’s permitting process page says contractors must submit a permit for any reroof, residential or commercial, through MyGov. A roof permit needs a site plan of the location, the roofing material, and HOA approval with an official letter. A plan review fee is due at submittal.

Town of Trophy Club. The town’s permitting page lists a general application that covers re-roof permits, with residential permits submitted online through the town’s portal. Contractors register with the town through the same portal, with insurance and other documents. Check the town’s fee schedule for the current fee.

Whether a smaller tile repair needs a permit depends on the scope, so check with the town for your project. We pull the permits.

HOA review

Both towns have neighborhoods with architectural review, and in Westlake the town itself asks for an official HOA approval letter with a reroof permit. Replacing a few broken tiles with an exact match usually isn’t an issue, but a new tile color, a new profile or a different roof material almost always needs approval first. Rules vary by neighborhood, so ask yours. We can get you manufacturer product sheets and samples for the submittal.

If the roof needs replacing: high-end options

If the inspection shows the tile is done, you still have good choices. These are the roofs I’d look at on a Westlake or Trophy Club home:

RoofLookWeightWorth knowing
New clay or concrete tileSame Mediterranean, Spanish or Tuscan lookHeavy; the house is already framed for itThe most direct replacement; HOAs usually approve a matching style
Standing seam metalClean lines, from modern to farmhouse to transitionalLight24 or 26 gauge; we run our own roll formers and metal lead time is typically 1 to 2 weeks. See Class 4 metal roofs and insurance.
EnviroshakeCedar shake or slate lookLighter than tileEnviroshake lists a UL 2218 Class 4 impact rating. See Enviroshake vs. cedar shake after hail.
Stone-coated steelTile or shake profiles in a textured finishLightA way to keep a tile look at much lower weight; see standing seam vs. stone-coated steel

Mixing works too: tile on the main roof with standing seam on porches, bays and low-slope sections is a classic look on these homes. See standing seam in Westlake, standing seam in Trophy Club, Enviroshake in Westlake and Enviroshake in Trophy Club. Ask your insurer in writing whether a Class 4 roof earns a discount on your policy; see the Texas impact-resistant roof discount guide.

After a storm: your 12-point tile roof checklist

  1. Write down the storm date and time.
  2. Walk the property in daylight and photograph tile pieces, mortar and dents on soft metals.
  3. Check gutters and downspout outlets for tile chips.
  4. Look over the roof from the yard with binoculars or a phone zoom for gaps and low tiles.
  5. Check the attic with a flashlight for wet decking or drips.
  6. Check ceilings and upstairs walls for new stains.
  7. Stay off the roof, and don’t let anyone walk it without a planned path.
  8. Find any spare tile from the original roof and set it aside.
  9. Get a tile inspection with drone photos and a slope-by-slope report.
  10. Ask that hail breaks be separated from old, foot-traffic and installation breaks.
  11. Ask what the underlayment looked like where tile was lifted.
  12. Decide on a claim with the report in hand, within the 1-year window; check your policy.

Questions to ask the roofer who inspects your tile roof

  • Will you fly a drone first, and where exactly will you walk?
  • Do you lift tile to check the underlayment, or only look at the surface?
  • How do you tell hail breaks from old breaks and foot-traffic breaks?
  • Can you identify my tile, and do you have a source for matching pieces?
  • If the underlayment is worn, do you do lift-and-relay with your own crews?
  • Who pulls the permit, and who handles the HOA letter?
  • What are the manufacturer and workmanship warranties, in writing?

Nearby towns

We inspect and repair tile roofs across northeast Tarrant and south Denton County, including Southlake, Roanoke, Keller and Colleyville. See tile roofing in Westlake, tile roofing in Trophy Club, tile roofing in Southlake, tile roofing in Roanoke and tile roofing in Colleyville.

Get your tile roof checked the right way

We’re certified with GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, Atlas, Johns Manville, Carlisle, Tropical Roofing Products, Mule-Hide and Enviroshake, and many other roof manufacturers. Snow Roofing & Exteriors is fully insured, has offices in Bridgeport, Decatur and Rhome, is A+ rated on the BBB, and has 5.0 stars on Google at all three offices: Bridgeport, Decatur and Rhome. References are available on request. Our workmanship warranty runs from 10 years up to lifetime, depending on the job.

Call (817) 733-9228 or request an estimate. We’ll fly the roof, walk only where it’s safe, lift tile where it counts, and give you a photo report that tells you exactly what the storm did and what it didn’t.

Frequently asked questions

Should I get on my tile roof after a hailstorm to look for damage?

No. Tile breaks under the wrong footstep, wet tile is slick, and a fall from a two-story roof is serious. Look from the ground, the driveway and the attic instead, and let a crew that works on tile inspect the roof. The Tile Roofing Industry Alliance recommends that only trained, insured professionals with fall protection walk a tile roof.

What size hail breaks clay or concrete tile?

It depends on the tile, its age and how it was installed. One forensic engineering firm, Vertex, writes that field observations and lab testing show hail under 2 inches in diameter generally won't damage competent, properly installed concrete or clay tile. Older, weathered or already-cracked tile can break at smaller sizes, and big hail can break any tile. That's why the hail size reported near your street matters, and why the roof still needs a close look.

How do you tell a hail crack from a tile that was already broken?

Fresh hail breaks have clean, unweathered edges, often with an impact mark, a crescent-shaped break at an edge, or a star pattern from the point of impact, and they show up on the slopes that faced the storm. Old breaks have dirty or stained edges and growth in the crack. Foot-traffic breaks tend to run along the batten lines or sit where people walk to vents, satellite dishes and HVAC equipment.

What is a slipped tile, and is it hail damage?

A slipped tile has slid down out of its course, leaving a gap above it and the underlayment showing. It usually means a failed nail, a broken nose or lug, or a cracked piece that let go, not hail by itself. We re-secure slipped tile to the manufacturer's method and check the underlayment underneath while it's open.

My tile looks fine after the storm, but I have a leak. Why?

On a tile roof, the underlayment under the tile is what keeps the house dry. A cracked tile can send water onto underlayment that's already dried out or torn, and that's where leaks start. If the underlayment is worn out, a lift-and-relay (taking the tile up, replacing the underlayment and flashings, and re-laying the same tile) often fixes it without buying a new roof.

Can you match my tile if a few pieces are broken?

Usually. We identify the maker, profile and color and look for current production, salvage stock or tile we can harvest from a hidden slope. Some products are no longer made; Lifetile concrete tile, for example, is discontinued, so matching it means salvage or harvesting. Keep any spare tiles left from your original roof.

Do I need a permit to repair or replace a tile roof in Westlake or Trophy Club?

For a re-roof, yes. The Town of Westlake says every reroof needs a permit submitted through MyGov, with a site plan, the roofing material and an official HOA approval letter. Trophy Club has a re-roof permit application and requires contractor registration through its online portal. For smaller tile repairs, check with the town for your exact scope. We pull the permits.

How long do I have to file a hail claim in Texas?

Generally 1 year from the date of loss in Texas, but check your policy, since some differ. Get the roof inspected first and file only if the inspection finds storm damage. Texas law also requires you to pay your deductible; a contractor may not waive, absorb or rebate it.

Get a free roof inspection

We get on the roof, photograph what we find, and tell you plainly whether you need a repair or a replacement.

Free Roof Replacement Estimate

📞 Call (817) 733-9228

Certified with GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, Atlas, Johns Manville, Carlisle, Tropical Roofing Products, Mule-Hide and Enviroshake

Atlas Roofing certified contractor
📞 (817) 733-9228